An anti-abortion activist rallies outside the Supreme Court on Nov. 1, as arguments about Texas’ abortion law begin. The court has allowed the law to remain in place for now.
Jacquelyn Martin/AP
hide caption
toggle caption
Jacquelyn Martin/AP
An anti-abortion activist rallies outside the Supreme Court on Nov. 1, as arguments about Texas’ abortion law begin. The court has allowed the law to remain in place for now.
Jacquelyn Martin/AP
The U.S. Supreme Court on Friday refused for a second time to block a Texas law that has virtually brought abortions to a halt for anyone more than six weeks pregnant, a time so early that many women don’t know they are pregnant. Separately, the court dismissed as improvidently granted the Justice Department’s challenge to the law, meaning the court should not have accepted the case in the first place.
In a fractured opinion, four of the court’s conservatives–Trump appointees Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett, plus Justice Samuel Alito left the providers a single tenuous route to challenging the law. Justice Clarence Thomas went further, saying that in his view, the providers could not challenge the law at all. And Chief Justice John Roberts, joined by the court’s three liberals, would have allowed a full throated challenge to the law to go forward.
Added all together, that boiled down to a vote of 8-1, with only Justice Thomas dissenting. But there was little agreement beyond that, with the conservative four making any continuation of the case nearly impossible, and the Roberts four strongly suggesting that the law is unconstitutional.
At issue in the case is S.B. 8, a law enacted by the Texas legislature to make constitutional challenges to the state’s newest anti-abortion law impossible. It was avowedly written as a way to skirt more than a half century of Supreme Court precedents establishing that the way to challenge the constitutionality of a state law is to sue state officials. So S.B. 8 removes enforcement of the state law from the hands of state officials and instead delegates enforcement to private citizens, empowering them to sue anyone who “aids and abets” an abortion after roughly 6 weeks, and putting a high price in damages for each abortion.
As the chief justice and the court’s liberals saw things, “The clear purpose of the law was to nullify the court’s constitutional rulings,” something that the high court has, since the founding era said is unconstitutional. Roberts drove his view home by quoting decisions from the founding era written by Chief Justice John Marshall.
“If the legislatures of the several states may at will annul the judgments of the courts of the United States, and destroy the rights acquired under those judgments,” wrote Marshall, “the constitution becomes a solemn mockery.”
Underlining the point, Roberts added, “The nature of the federal right infringed does not matter. It is the role of the Supreme Court in our constitutional system at is at stake.”
University of Texas law professor Stephen Vladeck said he was “stunned” to see that Roberts could not get the court’s other conservatives to join such a basic premise of constitutional law. He called the decision “radical,” asserting that it “has incredibly ominous implications for the ability of federal courts to strike down state laws that interfere with our constitutional rights, and more importantly for the ability of those whose rights are violated to actually have their day in court.
The decision in the Texas case came just days after the court heard arguments in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which directly challenges Roe v. Wade. But Florida State University professor Mary Ziegler says abortion rights supporters should take no comfort from Friday’s ruling to keep the challenge at least nominally alive.
“If you read the win for abortion providers here as some kind of positive sign in the Dobbs case, I think you’re deluding yourself,” she warns. ” Essentially what you see is the most conservative justices saying ‘it’s not Texas’ job to overrule Roe v. Wade. That’s our job and we’re going to do that job.'”
In the second case, the challenge brought by the Justice Department to force Texas to comply with existing abortion rights, the vote was also 8-1, but with Justice Sonia Sotomayor dissenting.
“The Court should have put an end to this madness months ago … It failed to do so then, and it fails again today,” she wrote.
Sotomayor said while she agreed with the court allowing the abortion providers to continue their challenges, she dissented “from the Court’s dangerous departure from its precedents, which establish that federal courts can and should issue relief when a State enacts a law that chills the exercise of a constitutional right and aims to evade judicial review.”
She said the court, by its decision, “effectively invites other States to refine” the Texas law’s model “for nullifying federal rights. The Court thus betrays not only the citizens of Texas, but also our constitutional system of government.”
The court’s decision came just a little more than a month after hearing expedited arguments in the case, on Nov. 1. And it allows the abortion providers to return to District Judge Robert Pitman who previously blocked the law, saying it violated the constitutional right to abortion. Pitman had twice been stymied in attempts to examine the constitutionality of the law.
At the time the court heard the arguments, its decision to revisit its own actions from a month earlier seemed to point to a change in position. But those hopes were dashed for abortion providers who had asked the court to intervene a second time, coupling their appeal with the one from the federal government. The U.S. Justice Department contended it had the right to enforce federal constitutional rights, including the right to an abortion upheld by the Supreme Court for nearly a half century. The court disagreed.
It goes into effect on Monday. and covers any indoor space that is not a private residence.
Noncompliance comes with fines up to $1,000 for each violation and local health departments are being asked to enforce the requirements. The measure will be reassessed on Jan. 15, Gov. Kathy Hochul said. In the meantime, here’s a look at three options the affected places will have starting Monday and what businesses, patrons and employees need to know about each of them. Learn more here.
Businesses and venues that implement a proof-of-vaccination requirement can accept Excelsior Pass, Excelsior Pass Plus, SMART Health Cards issued outside of New York state or a CDC Vaccination Card.
In accordance with CDC’s definition of fully vaccinated, full-course vaccination is defined as 14 days past an individual’s last vaccination dose in their initial vaccine series (14 days past the second shot of a two-dose Pfizer-BioNTech or Moderna vaccine; 14 days past the one-shot Janssen/Johnson & Johnson vaccine).
The state also accepts WHO-approved vaccines for these purposes. Parents and guardians can retrieve and store an Excelsior Pass and/or Excelsior Pass Plus for children or minors under legal guardianship.
New Yorkers can retrieve their Excelsior Pass or Excelsior Pass Plus here. Businesses and venues can download the Excelsior Pass Scanner app — free for any business nationwide and available in more than 10 languages — here.
Businesses and venues that implement a mask requirement must ensure all patrons 2 years and older wear a mask at all times while indoors.
3. Continued Masking Requirements
People who aren’t vaccinated are still responsible for wearing masks, in accordance with federal CDC guidance. The state’s masking requirements continue to be in effect for pre-K to grade 12 schools, public transit, homeless shelters, correctional facilities, nursing homes and healthcare settings per CDC guidelines.
New York state continues to strongly recommend mask-wearing in all public indoor settings as an added layer of protection, even when not required. Children under 5 who remain ineligible for vaccination must wear a proper-fitting mask.
COVID-19 vaccines and booster doses are free and widely available statewide. New Yorkers can visit vaccines.gov, text their ZIP code to 438829, or call 1-800-232-0233 to find nearby locations.
To schedule an appointment at a state-run mass vaccination site, New Yorkers can visit the Am-I-Eligible site or contact their health providers, county health departments, Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs), rural health centers or pharmacies.
New York City and New Jersey Vaccine Providers
Click on each provider to find more information on scheduling appointments for the COVID-19 Vaccine.
Data: City of New York, State of New Jersey • Nina Lin / NBC
More notably, approval of the White House response to the pandemic dropped to 46 percent compared to 48 percent disapproval — putting the president underwater in that category for the first time.
The approval rating for Biden’s handling of the economy sank to 37 percent compared to 56 percent disapproval.
The poll of 800 Americans nationwide has a margin of error of plus or minus 3.5 percentage points.
“The COVID [approval] number is actually I think the more important one,” Micah Roberts, partner at Public Opinion Strategies, the Republican pollster for the survey, told CNBC. “As goes COVID, so goes the Biden presidency, and that’s really proving to be quite true.”
The poll found that some 41 percent of Americans believe the economy will get worse in the next year, up slightly from the prior quarter’s survey but still a pessimistic reading.
It’s not just peripheral voters who are cooling on Biden, the survey shows. The president’s approval rating among people who voted for him has dropped from 80 percent in April to 69 percent in the latest reading, according to the survey.
Americans’ disapproval of Biden is trickling into their feelings about Democrats in Congress, too.
When asked which party they prefer to control Congress, 44 percent of Americans said they’d prefer Republicans, compared with just 34 percent who said they favor Democrats. That’s up from a 2-point edge Republicans had in the last survey.
“If the election were tomorrow, it would be an absolute unmitigated disaster for the Democrats,” Jay Campbell, partner at Hart Research Associates and the Democratic pollster for the survey, told CNBC.
WASHINGTON – Bob Dole is heading home to Kansas one last time.
The body of the former GOP Senate leader is returning to the state that launched his political career after two days of somber but warm ceremonies in the nation’s capital honoring the iconic Republican.
“Kansas’ favorite son,” recalled former Sen. Pat Roberts during a funeral service Friday at the Washington National Cathedral, where a bipartisan assemblage of politicians, led by President Joe Biden, honored Dole’s lasting legacy as a bridge-builder in Congress.
The services included two days of tributes reserved for Washington’s most consequential and revered dignitaries. Dole lay in state in the Capitol Rotunda Thursday as Biden, who served in the Senate with Dole, and congressional leaders heaped praise on him.
“America has lost one of our greatest patriots.” Biden said, while hailing him as “a hero of democracy.”
Friday’s tributes ended at the World War II Memorial on the National Mall where a throng of mourners heard actor Tom Hanks, NBC Today host Savannah Guthrie and Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, laud Dole, a decorated World War II veteran himself, as a national hero who always seemed in command.
“There are many great lessons to take away from Bob Dole’s life,” Hanks said. “Go to the other guy’s office so you can decide when the meeting is over, get up and walk out. Speak straight, even when it gets you in trouble because it will. But at least everyone will know how you stand and what you stand for. And always plan not just to win, but to win big. Yes, you may try and fail. But you will not fail to try.”
Dole’s casket is set to arrive in Kansas on Friday evening in preparation for a public memorial service Saturday in the gymnasium at Russell High School, Dole’s alma mater. His casket will then go to the Kansas Statehouse in Topeka where he will lie in repose beginning at 5 p.m.
His body will then return to Washington, and Dole will be buried at Arlington National Cemetery, according to a spokesman with Kansas GOP Sen. Jerry Moran’s office.
Gen. Mark Milley remembers Dole as ‘a man of deep character’
Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, honored Dole as “a man of deep character and tremendous accomplishment” in remarks at the World War II Memorial Friday afternoon.
“Today is a solemn day for our nation as we collectively mourn, but more importantly, we celebrate the life of Senator Bob Dole, an incredible example of a lifetime of selfless service to our nation,” Milley said.
Milley said Dole’s “commitment to this democracy was unwavering” and described the late-senator’s time in the military. Dole, a decorated World War II veteran, was seriously injured in Italy’s Apennine Mountains located in 1945.
“He had a life of service defending this democracy, and we honor him today for his entire life,” Milley said.
Dole’s service to the United States went beyond his military career, Milley said, noting the Kansas Republican went on to serve the country “many, many times over” in different arenas.
“He served the army. He served the state of Kansas. He served his political party but above all, he served his country and he served his fellow American,” Milley said. “Bob Dole always, always put his country first.”
– Rebecca Morin
Hanks: Dole ‘willed’ World War II Memorial into place as monument to peace
In paying tribute to Dole, Actor Tom Hanks said there was perhaps no more fitting location to remember him than the World War II Memorial since the Kansas senator and wounded World War II veteran “willed this memorial into place.”
“He pushed the idea. He corralled the votes. He made the phone calls. He enlisted allies, all of us in the cause. And he raised the money,” Hanks said of Dole who led the national fundraising effort. “He did all but mix the concrete himself, which he may have done had he had the use of that right arm.”
Hanks, who played the iconic role of Capt. John Miller in ‘Saving Private Ryan,’ noted Dole’s service in World War II where he was wounded and lost the use of his right arm during an attack against Nazi German forces in Italy.
“This memorial stands in this rightful sight because Bob Dole remembered. He remembered the nearly half a million souls who, unlike him, never came home from the Second World War. He remembered the years of service the surviving Americans had invested,” said Hanks, addressing a crowd that included World War II veterans.
“Yet this memorial was not built only for the generation it honors anymore than it was erected to crow of their victory,” the actor continued. “Bob Dole called this a memorial to peace, so that all generations would remember that peace is achieved in shared labor, by shared sacrifice, by volunteering for the shared duty, if peace is to be won, and if we Americans are to continue our pursuit of a more perfect nation in an imperfect world.”
– Ledyard King
Dole’s life a “flesh and blood” memorial to American values, says NBC’s Savannah Guthrie
NBC News’ Savannah Guthrie opened Dole’s second service of the day, held at the World War II memorial, describing his life as a memorial to American values made of “flesh and blood.”
Guthrie highlighted Dole’s role in advocating for the memorial’s creation and talked about his many visits to the monument, even in his final years.
“He came here looking for you: soldier, service member, caregiver, patriot,” Guthrie said. “He came to grasp your hand and lock eyes to convey what could never be sufficiently captured with words alone.”
Despite only knowing the Dole family for a few years, Guthrie reminisced about her memories with them, including a FaceTime call between her children and the Doles’ dogs.
“What a glorious surprise, so marvelous and unexpected, this treasure of a relationship, and inside it, a valuable lesson,” she said. “Senator Bob showed me that even well into your 90s, it is never too late to make a new friend.”
She added that Dole stood for dignity, integrity, friendship and his country.
Guthrie addressed Elizabeth Dole directly and honored their long marriage.
“Dearest Elizabeth, I know how deeply you grieve your beloved, how sweet was the company you kept for nearly 50 years, how you will miss the humor and charm of your dearest companion,” she said. “I also know of your deep faith and of his, and that connection between you is eternal and unbroken. It is how you will hold hands with him until you meet again.”
–Ella Lee
Bob Dole’ casket arrives at World War II Memorial
The casket of Bob Dole arrived at the National Mall where the former Kansas Republican senator, who died Sunday at age 98, will be honored at the World War II Memorial he helped establish. As the flag-draped coffin was unloaded, onlookers snapped photos while mourners sat quietly.
Dole, a World War II veteran wounded from Nazi gunfire in Italy in 1945, was known for his enduring work recognizing his fellow soldiers. Admirers spoke of how he would make impromptu visits to the memorial to greet veterans who came from across the nation on “Honor Flights.
Dedicated in 2004, the memorial honors the service of 16 million members of the U.S. armed forces, the support of countless millions on the home front, and the ultimate sacrifice of 405,399 Americans.
Twenty-four bronze bas-relief panels flank the ceremonial entrance. Granite columns representing each U.S. state and territory at the time of World War II ring a pool that shoots water into the air. Quotes, references to theaters, campaigns, and battles, and two massive victory pavilions marking (the European and Pacific theaters) chronicle the efforts Americans undertook to win the war. A wall of 4,048 gold stars reminds all of the supreme sacrifice made by over 400,000 Americans.
– Ledyard King
Dole’s casket heads to World War II for public memorial
Bob Dole’s flag-draped casket was led out of the National Cathedral following his funeral service and placed back in the hearse where it will head to the World War II Memorial on the National Mall for a public commemoration.
The memorial service for the former veteran, who was wounded in 1945 in Italy, is slated to start around 1:15 EST.
Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, will speak, along with friends of the Dole family, actor Tom Hanks and Savannah Guthrie of NBC News. Dole’s widow, Elizabeth, will lay a wreath at the memorial.
The World War II Memorial is part of Dole’s legacy, as he was national chairman in its fundraising effort.
– Ledyard King
Senate Chaplain described Dole, wife as ‘spiritual royalty’
Rev. Dr. Barry C. Black, the 62nd Senate Chaplain, said he grew to love Dole, despite not serving as chaplain while the Kansas senator held office.
He described a call with Dole and his wife, former Sen. Elizabeth Dole, as “a conference call with spiritual royalty.”
“At the end (of the call), I had a sense that Bob knew he was cared for by a great Shepherd,” Black said.
Black evoked one of the readings, Psalm 23, which reads “though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil: for thou art with me; thy rod and thy staff they comfort me.”
The Senate chaplain of 19 years joked that Dole enjoyed brevity and described him as a “covert spiritual agent.”
“He did not wear his religion on his sleeves,” Black said. “He resonated with the sentiment of Francis of Assisi: ‘Preach the Gospel everywhere you go. When necessary, use words.’”
– Ella Lee
‘The most generous person’: Robin Dole, daughter of late senator, honors father at funeral service
Robin Dole, the only daughter of the former GOP leader, hailed her father as an animal lover and “the most generous person” who “cared more about other than he did himself.”
“He was a giver, not a taker,” Dole, 67, said of her father. “He cared more about others than he did about himself.”
Dole recalled that her father had a “personal goal to help at least one person every day of his life.” She noted the Kansas Republican was unsure whether he was able to meet his goal.
“I said ‘Dad, you’ve got to be kidding. Some days you help one person and other days you help 40,000 people. I think you’ve met and exceeded your goal,’” Dole recalled.
“‘Well, you may be right,’ he said,” she continued.
Dole’s daughter: He was a lover of animals
Robin Dole said her father loved animals, noting how much he loved his dogs, Blazer and Leader. She said Blazer at times would lay at his feet “whenever he suspected dad needed special nursing care.”
“It really helped him because he loved them so much,” she said.
In her closing remarks, Dole quoted a farewell letter her father wrote.
“As I make the final walk on my life’s journey, I do so without fear because I know that I will again, not be walking alone,” Dole said, reading her father’s words. “I know that God will be walking with me.”
Dole added that she would miss her father so much, and will continue to talk to him every night.
“I love you dad,” she said. “You will never walk alone.”
– Rebecca Morin
Tom Daschle: Bob Dole transcended partisanship
Former Sen. Tom Daschle, who in the mid-1990s served as the Democratic majority leader while Dole was leading the Senate Republicans, praised the Kansan for possessing a love of country that transcended partisan politics.
“He stood up for minorities early in his career and he broke party ranks and voted for the landmark Civil Rights and Voting Rights acts. He stood up for the elderly when he worked with (New York Democratic Sen.) Pat Moynihan literally to save Social Security,” Daschle told the mourners. “He stood up for the young when he worked with my fellow South Dakotan (Democratic senator) George McGovern on nutrition assistance. And he stood up for the disabled when he worked with Ted Kennedy and Tom Harkin on the Americans with Disabilities Act.”
Dole said the agricultural community was particularly pleased when senators chose two Midwesterners to lead their respective parties in the chamber.
“He said every farmer in America that very moment ordered a new tractor,” he said, drawing a chuckle from the congregation.
– Ledyard King
Fellow Kansas Sen. Pat Roberts calls Dole ‘Kansas’ favorite son’
Former Sen. Pat Roberts, R-Kan., described Dole as “Kansas’ favorite son,” along with former President Dwight D. Eisenhower, and told stories of Dole’s upbringing in the Sunflower State.
The former Kansas senator evoked a speech Dole gave to the 1986 graduating class of his hometown high school, Russell High School.
“There are two kinds of education in this world,” Dole said. “There’s one where you give yourself and another you get from others. You could get an education on the farm, or in a factory or in a science lab, at a church pew. Most of all, if you’re from Russell, you can get an education just by looking at life around you.”
Roberts said when he learned the news of Dole’s death on Sunday, Kansans from all walks of life “paused,” including himself.
“Bob Dole was a person who meant something to everyone in the coffee shop, the campaign trail, the halls of Congress,” he said. “Whether we were in Topeka, Abilene, Wichita or Dodge City, I saw Bob Dole connect with Kansans, always on a personal level. He would share with them this vision, this promise, and he would help them achieve it.”
– Ella Lee
‘And there was Bob’
Roberts also spoke on Dole’s dedication to American veterans, particularly in his persistence to the creation of the World War II memorial.
“Every weekend, when the Honor Flights would roll up to the World War II memorial, Kansas veterans, escorted by Kansas high school students, would visit their memorial to reflect on their fight to preserve a free world,” he said. “And there was Bob, shaking every hand, posing for every picture, listening to all the stories and the thanks of a still grateful nation.”
– Ella Lee
Biden: Dole was ‘a man of principle, pragmatism and enormous integrity’
President Joe Biden honored Bob Dole Friday morning, calling the late senator a “genuine hero” as he described his life as a war hero and a politician who “always did his duty” and “lived by a code of honor.”
“I found Bob to be a man of principle, pragmatism and enormous integrity,” Biden said of the former GOP leader. “He wanted government to work, to work for folks like him, who came up the hard way.”
Biden, who served with Dole in the Senate, noted that the Kansas Republican at times made decisions that were in opposition of those within his own party, such as creating a federal holiday honoring Martin Luther King, Jr.
“Bob Dole did that,” Biden said, adding that the late Senator told colleagues that “No first class Democracy can treat people like second class citizens.”
During his closing remarks, Biden said Dole “will be with us always.”
“Bob will be with us always, cracking a joke, moving a bill, finding common ground,” Biden said.
– Rebecca Morin
Reverend: Bob Dole gone but ‘not lost’
Rev. Randolph Hollerith welcomed the mourners to the funeral, noting that it was only five weeks ago that former Secretary of State Colin Powell had his own memorial service in the very same church.
“We have indeed seen too much loss in recent days,” said Hollerith, dean of the Washington National Cathedral since 2016.
“Bob Dole was one of the greatest of the greatest generation, a patriot who always placed country above partisanship and politics. While we mourn his loss, we gather this morning to give thanks for him and to celebrate his extraordinary life,” the reverend said.
“Though Sen. Dole has gone from us he is not lost,” he said. “For now, it is enough to say on behalf of a grateful nation, well done, good and faithful servant. Well done.”
Ledyard King
Bill Clinton arrives at Bob Dole funeral service
Former President Bill Clinton is in attendance at Bob Dole’s funeral service at the Washington National Cathedral.
Clinton was seated in the first row, alongside President Joe Biden, first lady Jill Biden, Vice President Kamala Harris and second gentleman Doug Emhoff.
Clinton defeated Dole in the 1996 presidential election.
Former Vice Presidents Dan Quayle, Dick Cheney and Mike Pence were also in attendance. The three former vice presidents were seated together.
– Rebecca Morin
Ex-VPs Mike Pence, Dan Quayle, Dick Cheney attend Dole funeral service
Former Vice President Mike Pence arrived at the Washington National Cathedral around 10:15 a.m. EST Friday to attend Dole’s funeral service.
Pence wasn’t the only former vice president there. Dan Quayle and Dick Cheney were also in attendance.
A number of lawmakers will be at the funeral service for the former senator. Some members of Congress, such as Sens. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., and Susan Collins, R-Maine, were already in attendance at the Cathedral. Other lawmakers, as well as House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., and Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., will be arriving with the motorcade that left the Capitol.
President Joe Biden will also be in attendance and will deliver remarks honoring Dole.
– Rebecca Morin
Casket carrying Dole leaves Capitol for funeral service
The flag-draped casket carrying former Sen. Bob Dole has been loaded on a hearse and has left the Capitol for the six-mile trip to the Washington National Cathedral where a funeral service for the former GOP leader is scheduled to start at 11 a.m. EST.
The casket of the World War II veteran, who lay in state Thursday, was carried down the steps from the Capitol Rotunda by eight members of the military as congressional leaders looked on.
Dole’s widow, Elizabeth, and daughter, Robin, were part of the police escort taking the former presidential candidate to the funeral service.
A private service is scheduled at the cathedral where President Joe Biden and former Sens. Pat Roberts and Tom Daschle, and Dole’s daughter Robin Dole will give tribute. Lee Greenwood will perform.
The rookie Brooklyn Center Police officer who was training with Kim Potter on the day she fatally shot a black man during a traffic stop said the victim never reached for a gun, nor did he make any threatening gestures toward the officers.
Anthony Luckey made the shocking revelation as he testified on Wednesday as the state’s second witness in the trial of Potter, who is facing charges of first- and second-degree manslaughter in the death of 20-year-old Daunte Wright in Minneapolis in April.
It came one day after jurors were shown never-before-seen dash cam footage of the moment on April 11 when Potter collapsed to the ground screaming ‘I shot him, oh my God’ after she had aimed her gun instead of her Taser at fleeing Wright.
Luckey said he heard Potter yell ‘Taser! Taser! Taser!,’ a warning officers are supposed to give so their partners have time to move away. But almost immediately he saw a flash and smoke and heard the bang of Potter’s gun.
Luckey was so close to Potter when the shot was fired that the casing hit him in the face as it discharged. He said he still had hands on Wright when the bullet hit.
Prosecutors played distressing incident that also showed how Wright sped off in his car shortly after being shot, before coming to a stop when he hits another vehicle down the road.
Luckey’s account ultimately undermined the defense’s attempts to depict Potter’s decision to reach for a weapon as a justifiable move to protect the two officers in the event that Wright attacked or injured them in an effort to flee the scene.
Potter, who resigned from the police force five days after the fatal shooting, claims she mistakenly grabbed her gun instead of a Taser during the traffic stop.
SCROLL DOWN FOR VIDEO
Pictured: Anthony Luckey, Kim Potter’s trainee and witness to the shooting of Daunte Wright testifies on the first day of trial on Wednesday
Potter, a 26-year veteran in the force, claims she accidentally shot Daunte Wright (right) when she reached for her gun instead of her taser during a traffic stop over his expired plates in Brooklyn Center, Minnesota
The jury was shown body cam and dash cam footage of the dramatic moment Potter shot Wright dead after ‘accidentally’ pulling out her gun instead of her taser
Luckey was training with Potter when they pulled Wright over for a traffic stop before discovering he had an outstanding warrant for a weapons charge, he said during his testimony Wednesday.
Wright’s mother, Katie Bryant, 43, also testified on Wednesday while his girlfriend, Alayna Albrecht-Payton, 20, who was present in the car when the deadly shooting took place, took the stand on Thursday.
In the footage shown at the trial, the stunned Potter can be heard shouting hysterically, ‘I just shot him. I grabbed the wrong f**king gun’ immediately after firing her weapon.
Body camera footage of the stop shows Wright breaking free and getting back into his car while the officers attempted to detain him.
The word ‘Taser’ can be heard being repeated several times before Wright is fatally shot.
During cross-examination, Luckey said he had an ‘intuition’ to pull Wright over due to the ‘behavior of the vehicle,’ claiming it had a right blinker on despite the vehicle being in a left-turn lane.
Luckey said Wright was pulled over in a ‘high crime area’ known for ‘a lot of shootings.’
Matthew Frank, the assistant Minnesota Attorney General who also led the prosecution of ex-Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin, asked Luckey if Wright or his girlfriend ever reached for a weapon or made any threatening moves.
The officer testified that they did not.
Eldridge took the jury through the events from the moment Potter and her trainee, rookie officer Anthony Luckey first stopped Wright for having an air-freshener hanging from his rear view mirror and expired tags
A fellow cop is pictured on bodycam consoling Potter after Daunte Wright was shot and killed in Brooklyn Center, Minnesota
The jury was shown harrowing video of Wright’s distraught mother, pictured, arriving on the scene following a Facetime call in which she had seen her apparently lifeless son in his car
Wright’s girlfriend, who was in the car with him during the fatal traffic stop, recalled the shot being fired and the crash that followed as Wright struck another vehicle after driving off
Meanwhile, Albrecht-Payton took the stand at the start of the second day of the trial of Potter on Thursday, in testimony so emotional that the 20-year-old was at times almost unintelligible as she struggled to hold back her tears.
She told the court that she and Wright, both 20, were ‘just at the start’ of becoming boyfriend and girlfriend having only met a couple of weeks earlier over social media.
Later in the day the judge in the case, Regina Chu, slapped down a defense move for a mistrial. Potters lawyers argued unsuccessfully that prosecutors had spent the second day presenting ‘prejudicial evidence that had no relevance to the central questions of the case.
But it was Albrecht-Payton who provided the day’s most dramatic evidence. She was the one who answered Wright’s mother Katie Bryant’s frantic calls, turning the camera of her phone onto Bryant’s dying son.
She told the court about that call, saying: ‘It was his mom. She was asking what happened and I was delirious. I was screaming, ‘They shot him they shot him!’ and then I pointed the camera on him, and I’m so sorry I did that.
Albrecht-Payton told the court that she did not know what to do in the aftermath of the shooting. All she had in her head was images of CPR she had ‘seen on the movies or on TV.’
‘I didn’t know what to do I just put my hands over his chest and tried to hold it and scream his name and have him talk to me,’ she said.
‘I kept saying, ‘Daunte say something please, just talk to me,’ and he just didn’t. I know he wanted to. I replay that image in my head daily.’
In a brief cross-examination, defense counsel Earl Gray focused in on the hours before the traffic stop.
Albrecht-Payton admitted that she and Wright had split a joint at her mother’s home that morning but said that it didn’t have ‘any disabling effects,’ on either of them.
Albrecht-Payton said she did not recall if the car engine was off or on during the entire interaction with police.
She told Gray that she could only recall that ‘his hands were never on the wheel, only his foot was on the gas.’
Former Brooklyn Center cop Kim Potter, 49 (center), sits with her legal team during day two of her trial on Thursday
Location of the stop and crash: Officers tried to arrest Wright after pulling him and his girlfriend over for a traffic violation at about 2pm on April 11 before realizing he had an outstanding warrant
Officer Daniel Irish, of Champlin Police Department, took the stand Thursday afternoon to tell jurors how he and other officers battled in vain to save Wright
Eldridge and Gray repeatedly circled back on this point in both of their rebuttals. Whether or not the car engine was running is a central part of the state’s case that Potter’s behavior was reckless and in breach of Brooklyn Center Police Department’s own taser policy.
The second witness of the day gave testimony in an apparent bid by prosecutors to bolster their claims that Potter was reckless and endangered others with her use of force.
Patricia Lundgren was the 84-year-old driver of the car struck by Wright when he lost control of his car after he sped away having been shot.
Assistant Attorney General Matthew Frank questioned Lundgren, drawing out the sequence of the crash in which her husband, who was her passenger, was injured.
What Lundgren’s testimony lacked in drama was made up for by pictures of her smashed-up Subaru which were shown to the jury.
Jurors were later shown disturbing footage of Wright being pulled from his car, at gun point, his head lolling back as he was carried unconscious and bleeding and placed on the ground.
The images of officers administering CPR were shown in court but not broadcast according to an earlier order from Judge Regina Chu.
She has also ruled that autopsy photographs will be shown to the jury but not seen via the trial livestream.
The footage was shown as Officer Daniel Irish, of Champlin Police Department, took the stand Thursday afternoon to tell jurors how he and other officers battled in vain to save Wright.
Irish told jurors that he had checked for a pulse on Wright’s wrist and neck but found none.
Jurors saw bodycam footage of hysterical Albrecht-Payton immediately after Wright crashed his car after being shot
He placed a chest seal over the exit wound on Wright’s side then held the young man’s chin and kept his airways clear as a fellow officer administered CPR.
Defibrillator electrodes were applied to his chest and side to determine whether there was enough of a heartbeat to respond to a shock. There was not.
Ultimately, he said, a paramedic told officers to stop and pronounced Wright dead on the scene. Irish then helped get a sheet to cover up his body.
On audio of the bodycam footage a paramedic can clearly be heard saying, ‘No pulse. Grab that sheet.’
Jurors were also shown several still images.
The pictures were not broadcast and were shown to the court despite the defense’s objections.
They included a picture of Wright slumped at the wheel of his car, an image of officers attempting to save his life and one of a paramedic checking for a pulse.
Potter, a police officer for 26 years before she resigned five days after the shooting, has been charged on two counts; first-degree manslaughter predicated on reckless use/handling of a firearm and second-degree manslaughter.
With no criminal history, she is unlikely to receive the maximum sentence on either count should she be convicted. The maximum penalty for first degree manslaughter in Minnesota is 15 years but sentencing guidelines of 7-10 years mean she could be looking at less than half of that time behind bars.
But the prosecution has made it known that they intend to press for an upward departure from these sentencing guidelines and more prison time.
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court on Friday struck down the school mask mandate imposed by the administration of Gov. Tom Wolf, affirming a lower court ruling that said state health officials lacked the authority to set the blanket requirement for students across the state.
The ruling removed a previous order that allowed the mask mandate to remain in place while the Wolf administration appealed the Commonwealth Court ruling from last month. The Supreme Court justices did not issue an opinion on the case, but promised one would be coming.
Republicans said the ruling was an important check on executive overreach.
“We join the voices of millions of Pennsylvanians who are pleased to see our Commonwealth’s highest court agree that no unelected government bureaucrat should ever have the sole and unilateral authority to issue open-ended ‘orders’ — whether they focus on public health response or something else,” House Speaker Bryan Cutler (R., Lancaster) and House Majority Leader Rep. Kerry Benninghoff (R., Centre/Mifflin) said in a statement.
Senate President Pro Tempore Jake Corman (R., Centre), who as a parent joined the case as a plaintiff, said the decision meant “the power for parents and local leaders to make health and safety decisions in our schools is restored.”
A spokesperson for Wolf called the outcome “extremely disappointing.”
“The administration’s top priority from the beginning of this pandemic has been and remains protecting public health and safety, including students and staff, to ensure in-person learning continues,” said the spokesperson, Beth Rementer.
Rementer said the administration urged school districts to prioritize health and safety going forward. “Masking is a proven and simple way to keep kids in school without interruption and participate in sports and other extracurricular activities,” and is recommended by the CDC and the American Academy of Pediatrics, her statement said.
The order doesn’t necessarily mean an end to school masking: Some school systems have said they plan to continue requiring masks regardless of a state mandate — including Philadelphia, the state’s largest district. Others said Friday they were consulting with their solicitors.
In Cheltenham, Superintendent Brian Scriven told the community Thursday that regardless of the court’s decision, the district intended to require masking through the 2021-22 school year.
“We have a duty to keep our students, staff and community healthy and safe, and with the emergence of the omicron variant of COVID-19, many unknowns regarding its transmissibility and overall effects are at play,” Scriven said.
Enacted in September, when thousands of students statewide began returning to the classroom for the first time since the pandemic began, the mandate required all students, staff and visitors to wear masks inside public and private K-12 schools. Last month, as the case wound its way through the courts, Wolf announced his intention to lift the requirement in January in a bid to return “to a more normal setting.”
Wolf gave no indication that timetable would change, though COVID-19 cases have been rising again across the state, and the litigation continued.
The case didn’t turn on the reason for masking in schools. In the Commonwealth Court decision that initially struck down the mandate, Judge Christine Fizzano Cannon noted that the judges had “no opinion regarding the science or efficacy of mask-wearing or the politics underlying the considerable controversy the subject continues to engender.”
Instead, the litigation focused on the state’s authority to make that order. During oral arguments Wednesday, some justices seemed skeptical of the administration’s position that masking was a form of “modified quarantine” permitted under existing state law and regulations.
The plaintiffs who brought the case — Corman, State Rep. Jesse Topper (R., Bedford), and other parents and schools — had argued that Acting Health Secretary Alison Beam erred in not following a formal process to create a new regulation when she imposed the masking requirement after many school districts opted not to. Within days, court battles over the state mandate had begun.
In a statement, the group’s executive director hailed Friday’s ruling.
“Some government officials have used COVID to fundamentally reorder the nature of our government, and have violated democratic principles and personal liberty in the process,” Phill Kline said. “The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has agreed that this must stop.”
School mask mandates — or the right to impose them — have spurred litigation across the country. Some states have faced lawsuits for barring local school districts from requiring masks. The Arizona Supreme Court last month affirmed a decision striking down a state ban on school mask mandates, while states like Florida have maintained their bans, though with battles over enforcement.
Other states have required masks in schools — including neighboring New Jersey, where a federal judge this week rejected a challenge to the state’s school mask mandate.
Dismissing claims by parents that the requirement violated their children’s First Amendment rights, Judge Kevin McNulty wrote in an opinion Tuesday that “to be ‘muffled’ is not to be gagged.” He also dismissed an equal protection argument — saying that the mandate applied to all schools, and that it was rational for policymakers to impose it.
School administrators have also expressed concern about having to quarantine more students if masking were to be dropped, based on current rules for students who are close contacts of students who test positive for the virus.
Thomas W. King III, a lawyer for Corman and the other plaintiffs, said he anticipated some districts that keep masking requirements intact would face legal challenges over whether Pennsylvania law “delegates to school districts” the right to do so.
While the case decided a narrow issue, the ruling is “much more important than just masks,” King said. “The Supreme Court has proven that no one is above the law — not a governor, not a health secretary, and not anyone else who’s required to comply with the law before issuing mandates in Pennsylvania.”
Justice Gorsuch wrote that there were other ways to challenge the law beyond suing state officials in federal court, including by raising the unconstitutionality of the law as a defense in a state-court lawsuit brought under S.B. 8. He also noted that a state court judge had ruled in favor of abortion providers on Thursday.
That judge found that several procedural aspects of the law violated the state Constitution, including ones allowing people who had suffered no injury to sue and setting a minimum recovery of $10,000.
Abortion clinics in Texas welcomed the state-court ruling, but said that only a favorable decision from the Texas Supreme Court or the U.S. Supreme Court would allow them to start providing the procedure again without fear of crippling financial liability.
The decision in the Texas case came less than two weeks after the court heard a direct challenge to the right to abortion established in 1973 in Roe v. Wade, in a case about a Mississippi law that bans most abortions after 15 weeks. Roe prohibits states from banning abortion before fetal viability, the point at which fetuses can sustain life outside the womb, or about 23 to 24 weeks into a pregnancy.
The court’s six-member conservative majority seemed prepared to uphold the Mississippi law, and several justices indicated that they would vote to overrule Roe outright. A decision in the case is not expected until late June.
Understand the Supreme Court’s Momentous Term
Card 1 of 5
New York gun law. The justices will consider the constitutionality of a longstanding New York law that imposes strict limits on carrying guns in public. The court has not issued a major Second Amendment ruling in more than a decade.
A test for Chief Justice Roberts. The highly charged docket will test the leadership of Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., who lost his position at the court’s ideological center with the arrival last fall of Justice Amy Coney Barrett.
A drop in public support. Chief Justice Roberts now leads a court increasingly associated with partisanship. Recent polls show the court is suffering a distinct drop in public support following a spate of unusual late-night summer rulings in politically charged cases.
The Texas law flouts Roe’s viability line by barring abortions once fetal cardiac activity can be detected, usually around six weeks of pregnancy.
The law was challenged by abortion providers and the Biden administration. In addition to the court’s decision in the abortion providers’s case, it also issued a brief, unsigned opinion on Friday dismissing the Justice Department’s appeal, with only Justice Sotomayor noting a dissent.
WASHINGTON – Bob Dole is heading home to Kansas one last time.
The body of the former GOP Senate leader is returning to the state that launched his political career after two days of somber but warm ceremonies in the nation’s capital honoring the iconic Republican.
“Kansas’ favorite son,” recalled former Sen. Pat Roberts during a funeral service Friday at the Washington National Cathedral, where a bipartisan assemblage of politicians, led by President Joe Biden, honored Dole’s lasting legacy as a bridge-builder in Congress.
The services included two days of tributes reserved for Washington’s most consequential and revered dignitaries. Dole lay in state in the Capitol Rotunda Thursday as Biden, who served in the Senate with Dole, and congressional leaders heaped praise on him.
“America has lost one of our greatest patriots.” Biden said, while hailing him as “a hero of democracy.”
Friday’s tributes ended at the World War II Memorial on the National Mall where a throng of mourners heard actor Tom Hanks, NBC Today host Savannah Guthrie and Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, laud Dole, a decorated World War II veteran himself, as a national hero who always seemed in command.
“There are many great lessons to take away from Bob Dole’s life,” Hanks said. “Go to the other guy’s office so you can decide when the meeting is over, get up and walk out. Speak straight, even when it gets you in trouble because it will. But at least everyone will know how you stand and what you stand for. And always plan not just to win, but to win big. Yes, you may try and fail. But you will not fail to try.”
Dole’s casket is set to arrive in Kansas on Friday evening in preparation for a public memorial service Saturday in the gymnasium at Russell High School, Dole’s alma mater. His casket will then go to the Kansas Statehouse in Topeka where he will lie in repose beginning at 5 p.m.
His body will then return to Washington, and Dole will be buried at Arlington National Cemetery, according to a spokesman with Kansas GOP Sen. Jerry Moran’s office.
Gen. Mark Milley remembers Dole as ‘a man of deep character’
Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, honored Dole as “a man of deep character and tremendous accomplishment” in remarks at the World War II Memorial Friday afternoon.
“Today is a solemn day for our nation as we collectively mourn, but more importantly, we celebrate the life of Senator Bob Dole, an incredible example of a lifetime of selfless service to our nation,” Milley said.
Milley said Dole’s “commitment to this democracy was unwavering” and described the late-senator’s time in the military. Dole, a decorated World War II veteran, was seriously injured in Italy’s Apennine Mountains located in 1945.
“He had a life of service defending this democracy, and we honor him today for his entire life,” Milley said.
Dole’s service to the United States went beyond his military career, Milley said, noting the Kansas Republican went on to serve the country “many, many times over” in different arenas.
“He served the army. He served the state of Kansas. He served his political party but above all, he served his country and he served his fellow American,” Milley said. “Bob Dole always, always put his country first.”
– Rebecca Morin
Hanks: Dole ‘willed’ World War II Memorial into place as monument to peace
In paying tribute to Dole, Actor Tom Hanks said there was perhaps no more fitting location to remember him than the World War II Memorial since the Kansas senator and wounded World War II veteran “willed this memorial into place.”
“He pushed the idea. He corralled the votes. He made the phone calls. He enlisted allies, all of us in the cause. And he raised the money,” Hanks said of Dole who led the national fundraising effort. “He did all but mix the concrete himself, which he may have done had he had the use of that right arm.”
Hanks, who played the iconic role of Capt. John Miller in ‘Saving Private Ryan,’ noted Dole’s service in World War II where he was wounded and lost the use of his right arm during an attack against Nazi German forces in Italy.
“This memorial stands in this rightful sight because Bob Dole remembered. He remembered the nearly half a million souls who, unlike him, never came home from the Second World War. He remembered the years of service the surviving Americans had invested,” said Hanks, addressing a crowd that included World War II veterans.
“Yet this memorial was not built only for the generation it honors anymore than it was erected to crow of their victory,” the actor continued. “Bob Dole called this a memorial to peace, so that all generations would remember that peace is achieved in shared labor, by shared sacrifice, by volunteering for the shared duty, if peace is to be won, and if we Americans are to continue our pursuit of a more perfect nation in an imperfect world.”
– Ledyard King
Dole’s life a “flesh and blood” memorial to American values, says NBC’s Savannah Guthrie
NBC News’ Savannah Guthrie opened Dole’s second service of the day, held at the World War II memorial, describing his life as a memorial to American values made of “flesh and blood.”
Guthrie highlighted Dole’s role in advocating for the memorial’s creation and talked about his many visits to the monument, even in his final years.
“He came here looking for you: soldier, service member, caregiver, patriot,” Guthrie said. “He came to grasp your hand and lock eyes to convey what could never be sufficiently captured with words alone.”
Despite only knowing the Dole family for a few years, Guthrie reminisced about her memories with them, including a FaceTime call between her children and the Doles’ dogs.
“What a glorious surprise, so marvelous and unexpected, this treasure of a relationship, and inside it, a valuable lesson,” she said. “Senator Bob showed me that even well into your 90s, it is never too late to make a new friend.”
She added that Dole stood for dignity, integrity, friendship and his country.
Guthrie addressed Elizabeth Dole directly and honored their long marriage.
“Dearest Elizabeth, I know how deeply you grieve your beloved, how sweet was the company you kept for nearly 50 years, how you will miss the humor and charm of your dearest companion,” she said. “I also know of your deep faith and of his, and that connection between you is eternal and unbroken. It is how you will hold hands with him until you meet again.”
–Ella Lee
Bob Dole’ casket arrives at World War II Memorial
The casket of Bob Dole arrived at the National Mall where the former Kansas Republican senator, who died Sunday at age 98, will be honored at the World War II Memorial he helped establish. As the flag-draped coffin was unloaded, onlookers snapped photos while mourners sat quietly.
Dole, a World War II veteran wounded from Nazi gunfire in Italy in 1945, was known for his enduring work recognizing his fellow soldiers. Admirers spoke of how he would make impromptu visits to the memorial to greet veterans who came from across the nation on “Honor Flights.
Dedicated in 2004, the memorial honors the service of 16 million members of the U.S. armed forces, the support of countless millions on the home front, and the ultimate sacrifice of 405,399 Americans.
Twenty-four bronze bas-relief panels flank the ceremonial entrance. Granite columns representing each U.S. state and territory at the time of World War II ring a pool that shoots water into the air. Quotes, references to theaters, campaigns, and battles, and two massive victory pavilions marking (the European and Pacific theaters) chronicle the efforts Americans undertook to win the war. A wall of 4,048 gold stars reminds all of the supreme sacrifice made by over 400,000 Americans.
– Ledyard King
Dole’s casket heads to World War II for public memorial
Bob Dole’s flag-draped casket was led out of the National Cathedral following his funeral service and placed back in the hearse where it will head to the World War II Memorial on the National Mall for a public commemoration.
The memorial service for the former veteran, who was wounded in 1945 in Italy, is slated to start around 1:15 EST.
Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, will speak, along with friends of the Dole family, actor Tom Hanks and Savannah Guthrie of NBC News. Dole’s widow, Elizabeth, will lay a wreath at the memorial.
The World War II Memorial is part of Dole’s legacy, as he was national chairman in its fundraising effort.
– Ledyard King
Senate Chaplain described Dole, wife as ‘spiritual royalty’
Rev. Dr. Barry C. Black, the 62nd Senate Chaplain, said he grew to love Dole, despite not serving as chaplain while the Kansas senator held office.
He described a call with Dole and his wife, former Sen. Elizabeth Dole, as “a conference call with spiritual royalty.”
“At the end (of the call), I had a sense that Bob knew he was cared for by a great Shepherd,” Black said.
Black evoked one of the readings, Psalm 23, which reads “though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil: for thou art with me; thy rod and thy staff they comfort me.”
The Senate chaplain of 19 years joked that Dole enjoyed brevity and described him as a “covert spiritual agent.”
“He did not wear his religion on his sleeves,” Black said. “He resonated with the sentiment of Francis of Assisi: ‘Preach the Gospel everywhere you go. When necessary, use words.’”
– Ella Lee
‘The most generous person’: Robin Dole, daughter of late senator, honors father at funeral service
Robin Dole, the only daughter of the former GOP leader, hailed her father as an animal lover and “the most generous person” who “cared more about other than he did himself.”
“He was a giver, not a taker,” Dole, 67, said of her father. “He cared more about others than he did about himself.”
Dole recalled that her father had a “personal goal to help at least one person every day of his life.” She noted the Kansas Republican was unsure whether he was able to meet his goal.
“I said ‘Dad, you’ve got to be kidding. Some days you help one person and other days you help 40,000 people. I think you’ve met and exceeded your goal,’” Dole recalled.
“‘Well, you may be right,’ he said,” she continued.
Dole’s daughter: He was a lover of animals
Robin Dole said her father loved animals, noting how much he loved his dogs, Blazer and Leader. She said Blazer at times would lay at his feet “whenever he suspected dad needed special nursing care.”
“It really helped him because he loved them so much,” she said.
In her closing remarks, Dole quoted a farewell letter her father wrote.
“As I make the final walk on my life’s journey, I do so without fear because I know that I will again, not be walking alone,” Dole said, reading her father’s words. “I know that God will be walking with me.”
Dole added that she would miss her father so much, and will continue to talk to him every night.
“I love you dad,” she said. “You will never walk alone.”
– Rebecca Morin
Tom Daschle: Bob Dole transcended partisanship
Former Sen. Tom Daschle, who in the mid-1990s served as the Democratic majority leader while Dole was leading the Senate Republicans, praised the Kansan for possessing a love of country that transcended partisan politics.
“He stood up for minorities early in his career and he broke party ranks and voted for the landmark Civil Rights and Voting Rights acts. He stood up for the elderly when he worked with (New York Democratic Sen.) Pat Moynihan literally to save Social Security,” Daschle told the mourners. “He stood up for the young when he worked with my fellow South Dakotan (Democratic senator) George McGovern on nutrition assistance. And he stood up for the disabled when he worked with Ted Kennedy and Tom Harkin on the Americans with Disabilities Act.”
Dole said the agricultural community was particularly pleased when senators chose two Midwesterners to lead their respective parties in the chamber.
“He said every farmer in America that very moment ordered a new tractor,” he said, drawing a chuckle from the congregation.
– Ledyard King
Fellow Kansas Sen. Pat Roberts calls Dole ‘Kansas’ favorite son’
Former Sen. Pat Roberts, R-Kan., described Dole as “Kansas’ favorite son,” along with former President Dwight D. Eisenhower, and told stories of Dole’s upbringing in the Sunflower State.
The former Kansas senator evoked a speech Dole gave to the 1986 graduating class of his hometown high school, Russell High School.
“There are two kinds of education in this world,” Dole said. “There’s one where you give yourself and another you get from others. You could get an education on the farm, or in a factory or in a science lab, at a church pew. Most of all, if you’re from Russell, you can get an education just by looking at life around you.”
Roberts said when he learned the news of Dole’s death on Sunday, Kansans from all walks of life “paused,” including himself.
“Bob Dole was a person who meant something to everyone in the coffee shop, the campaign trail, the halls of Congress,” he said. “Whether we were in Topeka, Abilene, Wichita or Dodge City, I saw Bob Dole connect with Kansans, always on a personal level. He would share with them this vision, this promise, and he would help them achieve it.”
– Ella Lee
‘And there was Bob’
Roberts also spoke on Dole’s dedication to American veterans, particularly in his persistence to the creation of the World War II memorial.
“Every weekend, when the Honor Flights would roll up to the World War II memorial, Kansas veterans, escorted by Kansas high school students, would visit their memorial to reflect on their fight to preserve a free world,” he said. “And there was Bob, shaking every hand, posing for every picture, listening to all the stories and the thanks of a still grateful nation.”
– Ella Lee
Biden: Dole was ‘a man of principle, pragmatism and enormous integrity’
President Joe Biden honored Bob Dole Friday morning, calling the late senator a “genuine hero” as he described his life as a war hero and a politician who “always did his duty” and “lived by a code of honor.”
“I found Bob to be a man of principle, pragmatism and enormous integrity,” Biden said of the former GOP leader. “He wanted government to work, to work for folks like him, who came up the hard way.”
Biden, who served with Dole in the Senate, noted that the Kansas Republican at times made decisions that were in opposition of those within his own party, such as creating a federal holiday honoring Martin Luther King, Jr.
“Bob Dole did that,” Biden said, adding that the late Senator told colleagues that “No first class Democracy can treat people like second class citizens.”
During his closing remarks, Biden said Dole “will be with us always.”
“Bob will be with us always, cracking a joke, moving a bill, finding common ground,” Biden said.
– Rebecca Morin
Reverend: Bob Dole gone but ‘not lost’
Rev. Randolph Hollerith welcomed the mourners to the funeral, noting that it was only five weeks ago that former Secretary of State Colin Powell had his own memorial service in the very same church.
“We have indeed seen too much loss in recent days,” said Hollerith, dean of the Washington National Cathedral since 2016.
“Bob Dole was one of the greatest of the greatest generation, a patriot who always placed country above partisanship and politics. While we mourn his loss, we gather this morning to give thanks for him and to celebrate his extraordinary life,” the reverend said.
“Though Sen. Dole has gone from us he is not lost,” he said. “For now, it is enough to say on behalf of a grateful nation, well done, good and faithful servant. Well done.”
Ledyard King
Bill Clinton arrives at Bob Dole funeral service
Former President Bill Clinton is in attendance at Bob Dole’s funeral service at the Washington National Cathedral.
Clinton was seated in the first row, alongside President Joe Biden, first lady Jill Biden, Vice President Kamala Harris and second gentleman Doug Emhoff.
Clinton defeated Dole in the 1996 presidential election.
Former Vice Presidents Dan Quayle, Dick Cheney and Mike Pence were also in attendance. The three former vice presidents were seated together.
– Rebecca Morin
Ex-VPs Mike Pence, Dan Quayle, Dick Cheney attend Dole funeral service
Former Vice President Mike Pence arrived at the Washington National Cathedral around 10:15 a.m. EST Friday to attend Dole’s funeral service.
Pence wasn’t the only former vice president there. Dan Quayle and Dick Cheney were also in attendance.
A number of lawmakers will be at the funeral service for the former senator. Some members of Congress, such as Sens. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., and Susan Collins, R-Maine, were already in attendance at the Cathedral. Other lawmakers, as well as House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., and Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., will be arriving with the motorcade that left the Capitol.
President Joe Biden will also be in attendance and will deliver remarks honoring Dole.
– Rebecca Morin
Casket carrying Dole leaves Capitol for funeral service
The flag-draped casket carrying former Sen. Bob Dole has been loaded on a hearse and has left the Capitol for the six-mile trip to the Washington National Cathedral where a funeral service for the former GOP leader is scheduled to start at 11 a.m. EST.
The casket of the World War II veteran, who lay in state Thursday, was carried down the steps from the Capitol Rotunda by eight members of the military as congressional leaders looked on.
Dole’s widow, Elizabeth, and daughter, Robin, were part of the police escort taking the former presidential candidate to the funeral service.
A private service is scheduled at the cathedral where President Joe Biden and former Sens. Pat Roberts and Tom Daschle, and Dole’s daughter Robin Dole will give tribute. Lee Greenwood will perform.
“We have said all along that in order to fully restore abortion access in Texas, we need a decision in the U.S. Supreme Court or the Texas Supreme Court,” said Julie Murray, a senior staff attorney at Planned Parenthood. “Today’s decision is a step in the right direction, but it is not enough relief for abortion providers.”
In his opinion, Judge Peeples wrote that the Texas Legislature did not have a right under the state’s Constitution to allow people who had not suffered any injury from a violation of the abortion law to come into court and sue. He also found that the granting of awards of “no less than $10,000” to anyone successful in their suits violated the right to due process under the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.
Judge Peeples wrote that the law’s mechanism of delegating enforcement power to private citizens, if found constitutional, could be applied to all manner of contentious issues, including guns, same-sex marriage, freedom of speech and climate change.
“We are a diverse and creative people and it seems naïve to hope that these procedures will be cabined voluntarily,” he wrote.
Abortion providers said that if the ruling were upheld by the State Supreme Court, they would again begin providing abortions beyond six weeks of pregnancy because the law could not be enforced.
London — A British appellate court opened the door Friday for Julian Assange to be extradited to the United States by overturning a lower court ruling that found the WikiLeaks founder’s mental health was too fragile to withstand the American criminal justice system.
The High Court in London ruled that U.S. assurances were enough to guarantee Assange would be treated humanely and directed a lower court judge to send the extradition request to the home secretary for review. The home secretary, who oversees law enforcement in the U.K., will make the final decision on whether to extradite Assange.
But Assange’s fiance, Stella Moris, said the ruling would be appealed “at the earliest possible moment,” according to the Reuters news service.
Assange wasn’t in court, Reuters added. He denies any wrongdoing.
The Press Association, a British news agency, quoted Moris as assailing the court’s reasoning. She said, “I want to emphasize that the High Court accepted all the medical evidence and the conclusions of the magistrate that if Julian is extradited and placed under extreme conditions of isolation, it will drive him to take his own life — that extradition is oppressive.
“Yet the High Court decided against Julian on this occasion on the basis of political assurances, non-assurances, that the U.S. has given to the U.K. government. “I say non-assurances — Amnesty International says non-assurances — Amnesty International has analyzed these assurances and has said that they are inherently unreliable.
“They incorporate the possibility of breaking those assurances in their very wording.”
A lower court judge earlier this year refused an American request to extradite Assange to face spying charges over WikiLeaks’ publication of secret military documents a decade ago. District Judge Vanessa Baraitser denied extradition on health grounds, saying Assange was likely to kill himself if held under harsh U.S. prison conditions.
In appealing that decision at the High Court in London, an attorney for the U.S. government denied that Assange’s mental health was too fragile to withstand the U.S. judicial system. Lawyer James Lewis said Assange “has no history of serious and enduring mental illness” and doesn’t meet the threshold of being so ill that he can’t resist harming himself.
U.S. authorities have also told British judges that if the judges agree to let Assange be extradited, he could serve any U.S. prison sentence he receives in his native Australia.
U.S. prosecutors indicted Assange on 17 espionage charges and one charge of computer misuse over WikiLeaks’ publication of thousands of leaked military and diplomatic documents. The charges carry a maximum sentence of 175 years in prison, although Lewis said “the longest sentence ever imposed for this offense is 63 months.”
The classified military documents concerned the U.S. wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.
Assange, 50, is being held at London’s high-security Belmarsh Prison.
The case “has become a cause celebre for free speech,” Agence France-Presse points out, with Assange’s backers asserting WikiLeaks has the same rights as other media outlets to publish secret material in the public interest.
Assange backers outside the court demanded his immediate release from Belmarsh, AFP added.
Download our Free App
For Breaking News & Analysis Download the Free CBS News app
ATLANTA, Dec 10 (Reuters) – Weeks after the 2020 election, a Chicago publicist for hip-hop artist Kanye West traveled to the suburban home of Ruby Freeman, a frightened Georgia election worker who was facing death threats after being falsely accused by former President Donald Trump of manipulating votes. The publicist knocked on the door and offered to help.
The visitor, Trevian Kutti, gave her name but didn’t say she worked for West, a longtime billionaire friend of Trump. She said she was sent by a “high-profile individual,” whom she didn’t identify, to give Freeman an urgent message: confess to Trump’s voter-fraud allegations, or people would come to her home in 48 hours, and she’d go to jail.
Freeman refused. This story of how an associate of a music mogul pressured a 62-year-old temporary election worker at the center of a Trump conspiracy theory is based on previously unreported police recordings and reports, legal filings, and Freeman’s first media interview since she was dragged into Trump’s attempt to reverse his election loss.
Kutti did not respond to requests for comment. Her biography for her work at the Women’s Global Initiative, a business networking group, identifies her as a member of “the Young Black Leadership Council under President Donald Trump.” It notes that in September 2018, she “was secured as publicist to Kanye West” and “now serves as West’s Director of Operations.”
When Kutti knocked on Freeman’s door on Jan. 4, Freeman called 911. By then, Freeman said, she was wary of strangers.
Starting on Dec. 3, Trump and his campaign repeatedly accused Freeman and her daughter, Wandrea “Shaye” Moss, of illegally counting phony mail-in ballots after pulling them from mysterious suitcases while working on Election Day at Atlanta’s State Farm Arena. In fact, the “suitcases” were standard ballot containers, and the votes were properly counted, county and state officials quickly confirmed, refuting the fraud claims.
But Trump and his allies continued to accuse Freeman and Moss of election-rigging. The allegations inspired hundreds of threats and harassing messages against them and their family members.
By the time Kutti arrived, Freeman needed help but was cautious and wouldn’t open the door because of the threats, according to Freeman and a police report.
So Freeman asked a neighbor to come over and talk with Kutti, who was with an unidentified male. Like Freeman, Kutti and the other visitor were Black. Kutti told the neighbor that Freeman was in danger and that she’d been sent to provide assistance. Freeman said she was open to meeting them. She asked Cobb County Police to send an officer to keep watch so she could step outside, according to a recording of her 911 call.
“They’re saying that I need help,” Freeman told the dispatcher, referring to the people at her door, “that it’s just a matter of time that they are going to come out for me and my family.”
An officer arrived and spoke with Kutti, who described herself as a “crisis manager,” according to the police incident report.
Kutti repeated that Freeman “was in danger” and had “48 hours” before “unknown subjects” turned up at her home, the report said. At the officer’s suggestion, the women agreed to meet at a police station. The officer’s report did not identify the man accompanying Kutti.
‘YOU’RE A LOOSE END’
Inside the station, Kutti and Freeman met in a corner, according to footage from a body camera worn by an officer present at the meeting. Reuters obtained the video through a public-records request.
1/2
Rapper Kanye West shows President Donald Trump his mobile phone during a meeting in the Oval Office at the White House in Washington, U.S., October 11, 2018. REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque
“I cannot say what specifically will take place,” Kutti is heard telling Freeman in the recording. “I just know that it will disrupt your freedom,” she said, “and the freedom of one or more of your family members.”
“You are a loose end for a party that needs to tidy up,” Kutti continued. She added that “federal people” were involved, without offering specifics.
Kutti told Freeman that she was going to put a man Kutti identified as “Harrison Ford” on speakerphone. (Freeman said the man on the phone wasn’t the actor by the same name.) Kutti said the man had “authoritative powers to get you protection,” she said.
At that point, Kutti can be heard asking the officer to give them privacy. The body camera did not capture a clear recording of the conversation that followed after the officer moved away from the two women.
Kutti and the man on the speakerphone, over the next hour, tried to get Freeman to implicate herself in committing voter fraud on Election Day. Kutti offered legal assistance in exchange, Freeman said.
“If you don’t tell everything,” Freeman recalled Kutti saying, “you’re going to jail.”
Growing suspicious, Freeman said she jumped up from her chair and told Kutti: “The devil is a liar,” before calling for an officer.
Later at home, Freeman said, she Googled Kutti’s name and discovered she was a Trump supporter.
Police say they did not investigate the incident further.
West, who changed his name in October to “Ye,” did not respond to requests for comment sent through another publicist who represents him.
Reuters could not independently confirm whether Kutti still works for West, or in what capacity.
Media reports have cited her association with the rapper since 2018, when she ceased working with R. Kelly, an R&B singer who was convicted in September of racketeering and sex-trafficking charges. Kutti’s biography says she is the founder of Trevian Worldwide, a media and entertainment advisory firm with offices in four cities. Among her clients, she says, are boxer Terence Crawford and Queen Rania Al Abdullah of Jordan.
The meeting took place two months after West ended a failed bid for the White House that drew media attention when several publications revealed that allies and supporters of Trump were working on the ground to advance West’s campaign. Some Democrats said they regarded West’s presidential bid as a ruse to siphon off Black votes from Democrat Joe Biden. Groups assisting the rapper’s campaign denied that charge.
On Jan. 5, the day after Freeman’s meeting with Kutti, an agent from the Federal Bureau of Investigation called Freeman and urged her to leave her home of 20 years because it wasn’t safe, Freeman said.
The following day, Jan. 6, Kutti’s prediction that people would descend on Freeman’s home in 48 hours proved correct, according to a defamation lawsuit Freeman and Moss filed last week against a far-right news site. Freeman, the lawsuit said, left hours before a mob of angry Trump supporters surrounded her home, shouting through bullhorns.
WASHINGTON – Family, friends and members of Congress are paying tribute to Bob Dole at his funeral at the Washington National Cathedral on Friday, a day after President Joe Biden and congressional leaders honored the Senate’s longest-serving Republican leader as he lay in state at the U.S. Capitol.
Dole’s casket was loaded onto a hearse at the Capitol and taken to the cathedral, where a private service started shortly after 11 a.m. EST.
Biden, former Sens. Pat Roberts and Tom Daschle, and Dole’s daughter Robin Dole will give tributes, and Lee Greenwood will perform.
Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, will also speak, along with friends of the Dole family, actor Tom Hanks and Savannah Guthrie of NBC News. Dole’s widow, Elizabeth, will lay a wreath at the memorial.
Following the church service, around 1:15 p.m. EST, Dole’s motorcade and casket will drive to the National World War II Memorial on the National Mall and stop there to honor the life and service of the World War II veteran. Dole helped build the memorial as national chairman of its fundraising effort.
Memorials will shift to Dole’s home state of Kansas on Saturday. His body will then return to Washington. Burial details have not been announced.
Reverend: Bob Dole gone but ‘not lost’
Rev. Randolph Hollerith welcomed the mourners to the funeral, noting that it was only five weeks ago that former Secretary of State Colin Powell had his own memorial service in the very same church.
“We have indeed seen too much loss in recent days,” said Hollerith, dean of the Washington National Cathedral since 2016.
“Bob Dole was one of the greatest of the greatest generation, a patriot who always placed country above partisanship and politics. While we mourn his loss, we gather this morning to give thanks for him and to celebrate his extraordinary life,” the reverend said.
“Though Sen. Dole has gone from us he is not lost,” he said. “For now, it is enough to say on behalf of a grateful nation, well done, good and faithful servant. Well done.”
Ledyard King
Bill Clinton arrives at Bob Dole funeral service
Former President Bill Clinton is in attendance at Bob Dole’s funeral service at the Washington National Cathedral.
Clinton was seated in the first row, alongside President Joe Biden, first lady Jill Biden, Vice President Kamala Harris and second gentleman Doug Emhoff.
Clinton defeated Dole in the 1996 presidential election.
Former Vice Presidents Dan Quayle, Dick Cheney and Mike Pence were also in attendance. The three former vice presidents were seated together.
– Rebecca Morin
Ex-VPs Mike Pence, Dan Quayle, Dick Cheney attend Dole funeral service
Former Vice President Mike Pence arrived at the Washington National Cathedral around 10:15 a.m. EST Friday to attend Dole’s funeral service.
Pence wasn’t the only former vice president there. Dan Quayle and Dick Cheney were also in attendance.
A number of lawmakers will be at the funeral service for the former senator. Some members of Congress, such as Sens. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., and Susan Collins, R-Maine, were already in attendance at the Cathedral. Other lawmakers, as well as House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., and Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., will be arriving with the motorcade that left the Capitol.
President Joe Biden will also be in attendance and will deliver remarks honoring Dole.
– Rebecca Morin
Casket carrying Dole leaves Capitol for funeral service
The flag-draped casket carrying former Sen. Bob Dole has been loaded on a hearse and has left the Capitol for the six-mile trip to the Washington National Cathedral where a funeral service for the former GOP leader is scheduled to start at 11 a.m. EST.
The casket of the World War II veteran, who lay in state Thursday, was carried down the steps from the Capitol Rotunda by eight members of the military as congressional leaders looked on.
Dole’s widow, Elizabeth, and daughter, Robin, were part of the police escort taking the former presidential candidate to the funeral service.
A private service is scheduled at the cathedral where President Joe Biden and former Sens. Pat Roberts and Tom Daschle, and Dole’s daughter Robin Dole will give tribute. Lee Greenwood will perform.
Migrants are regularly packed into trucks or cars as they make the journey north, and frequently fall prey to violence along the way. In January, the bodies of 19 people, most of them migrants, were found in a charred pickup truck near the U.S. border. Twelve police officers were later arrested in connection with the crime.
At least 3,575 deaths have been documented on the United States-Mexico border since 2014, according to the International Organization for Migration, with 650 people killed attempting to cross the U.S. border this year alone — the highest number since the agency began documenting deaths in 2014.
“The rising migrant death toll in the region is highly alarming,” Michele Klein-Solomon, the organization’s regional director for Central, North America and the Caribbean, said in a statement on Wednesday.
At least 750 migrants have been killed trying to cross Mexico since 2014, according to the agency, and thousands more have simply disappeared.
Thursday’s accident occurred one day after the United States relaunched a contentious migrant enforcement program known as Remain in Mexico, which would force asylum seekers to wait across the border while their cases are determined in U.S. courts. The program has been criticized by human rights groups because of the unsafe conditions migrants face in Mexico.
“Under the Remain in Mexico program, the United States and Mexico have knowingly put thousands of asylum seekers’ lives in danger,” Ari Sawyer, a researcher for Human Rights Watch, said in a statement Thursday.
WASHINGTON, Dec 9 (Reuters) – A U.S. appeals court on Thursday rejected a request by former President Donald Trump to withhold records from the House of Representatives probe of the deadly Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol, saying he had provided “no basis” for his request.
“Former President Trump has provided no basis for this court to override President Biden’s judgment,” a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit wrote.
President Joe Biden had previously determined that the records, which belong to the executive branch, should not be subject to executive privilege and that turning them over to Congress was in the best interest of the nation.
“Both branches agree that there is a unique legislative need for these documents and that they are directly relevant to the Committee’s inquiry into an attack on the legislative branch and its constitutional role in the peaceful transfer of power,” the court said.
The ruling marks yet another blow to the Republican former president, who has waged an ongoing legal battle with the committee over access to documents and witnesses.
The House Select Committee investigating the riot has asked the National Archives, the U.S. agency housing Trump’s White House records, to produce visitor logs, phone records and written communications between his advisers.
The panel has said it needs the records to understand any role Trump may have played in fomenting the violence.
1/2
Security fencing is seen near the U.S. Capitol ahead of an expected rally Saturday in support of the January 6 Capitol attack defendants in Washington, U.S. September 17, 2021. REUTERS/Michael Weekes/File Photo
Trump has argued that the materials requested by the House committee were covered by the executive privilege legal doctrine that protects the confidentiality of some White House communications.
Democratic Representative Bennie Thompson, who heads the select committee, and its vice chair, Republican Liz Cheney, issued a statement applauding the court decision which they said respected the panel’s interest in obtaining the records.
“We will get to the truth,” they said.
Trump’s lawyers have called the Democratic-led investigation politically motivated, and argue that the documents are protected.
This is now the second time a federal court has ruled against Trump in the matter.
U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan on Nov. 9 rejected Trump’s arguments, saying he had not acknowledged the “deference owed” to Biden’s determination that the committee could access the records. adding: “Presidents are not kings, and Plaintiff is not President.”
The court on Thursday gave Trump 14 days to file an emergency request to the Supreme Court to appeal the ruling.
“Regardless of today’s decision by the appeals court, this case was always destined for the Supreme Court,” Trump lawyer Liz Harrington tweeted.
In an emotional statement outside the court, Ms Moris said: “For the past… two years and a half, Julian has remained in Belmarsh prison, and in fact he has been detained since 7 December 2010 in one form or another, 11 years. For how long can this go on?”
This is a widget area - If you go to "Appearance" in your WP-Admin you can change the content of this box in "Widgets", or you can remove this box completely under "Theme Options"