ISTANBUL/WASHINGTON/BRUSSELS, May 18 (Reuters) – When Finland and Sweden signalled they were thinking of making the historic decision joining NATO, the alliance expected a tough response from Moscow, not from one of its own.
Yet at a gathering of NATO foreign ministers with their Finnish and Swedish counterparts on Saturday to celebrate the biggest shift in European security in decades, Turkey’s participant darkened the mood.
Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu was “in crisis mode”, a NATO diplomat told Reuters of the evening meeting in Berlin. A day earlier Turkey’s president, Tayyip Erdogan, had shocked fellow NATO members by saying he could not support membership for either Finland or Sweden.
Cavusoglu not only set conditions for Turkey accepting the membership bids but raised his voice at Sweden’s Ann Linde in what three NATO diplomats said was an “embarrassing” break in protocol.
“For us it was a historic moment and yet Cavusoglu said he was irritated at Linde’s ‘feminist policy’, bringing so much drama,” another NATO diplomat said, describing a very tense atmosphere in the German foreign ministry in Berlin, in which many allies opted for silence to calm the situation.
“We were trying to understand what our Turkish colleague wanted – you know, really wanted,” said the diplomat, who like others spoke on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the issue. “It was embarrassing.”
Ankara’s main demands are for the Nordic countries to halt support for Kurdish militant groups present on their territory, and to lift their bans on some sales of arms to Turkey.
A Turkish diplomatic source said Cavusoglu had outlined Turkey’s stance respectfully, rejecting what he said was an allegation from Linde that its opposition was due to Sweden’s feminist foreign policy.
“Her comments are not helping Sweden’s NATO bid, while the statements coming from Finland are carefully crafted,” the source said. Sweden’s foreign ministry did not immediately respond to a request for comment after business hours.
Spurred on by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, both countries applied to join NATO on Wednesday. read more
Russia, which says the threat posed by NATO expansion was a major reason it sent troops into Ukraine, has played it cool.
While Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said Finland and Sweden joining was a “grave mistake” with “far-reaching consequences”, President Vladimir Putin said on May 16 their bids to join NATO posed no direct threat to Russia.
CONTACT MADE
The souring mood at Saturday’s meeting was all the more surprising because NATO diplomats had told Reuters in early May that all 30 allies supported Finland and Sweden’s accession to the alliance because of the security benefits it would bring. read more
NATO allies had wanted to seal their accession in record time as a way of solidifying their response to Russia, yet on Monday, Erdogan said the Swedish and Finnish delegations should not come to Ankara as planned.
On Wednesday, the Turkish presidency said a key Erdogan adviser had spoken with counterparts from Sweden, Finland, Germany, the United Kingdom and United States. NATO membership progess was only possible if Turkey’s expectations were met, it said. read more
One person close to the situation gave a more upbeat assessment, saying the conversation with Sweden was positive and opened the door for the delegation visits next week. Yet the calls on Wednesday came after five days of struggles by the Nordic countries to reach Erdogan’s office, the person said.
“All this is muddying the waters, but not holding up the overall accession plan,” the person said, under condition of anonymity.
Ankara says the arms ban – adopted by the Nordic countries in response to Turkey’s 2019 military incursion into northern Syria against Kurdish militants – is inappropriate for prospective members of a security pact.
Turkish state broadcaster TRT said Sweden and Finland had not approved Turkey’s request for the repatriation of 33 people with alleged links to groups it sees as terrorists. The chairman of the Swedish parliament’s Foreign Affairs Committee, Kenneth Forslund, said a solution could be found, but elsewhere.
“That Sweden would start expelling people who are not considered terrorists according to the terror lists the EU has, that’s totally unthinkable,” he said.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Diplomats in European capitals say they have seen brinkmanship from Erdogan before leading to a deal. An unpredictable but strategically crucial NATO ally, Turkey under Erdogan has pursued an independent foreign policy but remains a big contributor to NATO missions.
The tension has clouded ties between Washington and Ankara just as they appeared to have improved following five years of disagreements on Syria, Turkey’s closer ties with Moscow, and the erosion of rights and freedoms in the country.
Cavusoglu met U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken in New York later on Wednesday.
“We are seeing the winds of the Cold War again,” Cavusoglu told members of the Turkish American community late on Tuesday.
The source close to the process said Cavusoglu is taking a hard line publicly, pushed by Erdogan, but that there is a risk foreign allies will isolate Turkey if he goes too far.
At home, Erdogan faces tight elections by mid-2023 and his jabs at Europe play to domestic nationalist sentiment.
The United States is still confident of a solution. Blinken told a news conference on Sunday talks were ongoing over the differences between Turkey, Finland and Sweden.
“When it comes to the membership process, I am very confident that we will reach consensus,” he said.
Trump threw the embattled congressman a lifeline ahead of his Tuesday primary, posting on Truth Social — Trump’s social media platform — an appeal for voters to “give Madison a second chance.” In his post, Trump wrote that Cawthorn had recently “made some foolish mistakes, which I don’t believe he’ll make again.”
“My record is unparalleled, my endorsements, it’s totally unparalleled. Nobody’s ever had a record like this. I’m almost unblemished,” Trump said during an interview with David Brody on the Christian Broadcasting Network’s show “The 700 Club.”
Trump said on the show that Republicans should be afraid of him if their views didn’t line up with his. “Because if I endorsed them, they win, and if I don’t endorse them, they don’t win. I mean, that’s almost 100% of the case,” the former President said.
A Trump-backed GOP win is certainly not guaranteed if this week’s results are anything to go by. Another Trump-endorsed political candidate, Charles Herbster, lost his gubernatorial race in Nebraska last week amid allegations of sexual assault from eight women.
(CNN)Pennsylvania Republicans chose an election denier Tuesday as their candidate for governor in this year’s midterm elections — but appear to have rejected a far-right Senate contender.
This is CNBC’s live blog tracking developments on the war in Ukraine. See below for the latest updates.
Finland and Sweden formally applied to join NATO on Wednesday marking another step toward the Western military alliance’s expansion, although the full accession process could take a year and Turkey’s objections need to be overcome.
The status of the besieged Azovstal steelworks complex in Mariupol, a heavily-destroyed port city in southern Ukraine, remains unknown with Ukraine tight-lipped about how many soldiers may still be in the plant.
Ukraine’s Deputy Defence Minister Hanna Maliar said on Tuesday that Kyiv knew how many soldiers were still holed up at the plant but refused to disclose the number saying the information was “sensitive.”
More than 260 Ukrainian fighters, including some who are badly wounded, were evacuated Monday and taken to areas under Russia’s control, the Ukrainian military said, and further evacuations were due to take place. Russia claimed soldiers in the plant had “surrendered.” The fate of the city hangs in the balance now, with Russia poised to take full control.
Meanwhile, Ukraine says the Russian army has lost 27,900 soldiers since its invasion of Ukraine on Feb. 24, according to NBC News.
U.S. best positioned to deal with global economic uncertainty triggered by Russia’s war, Yellen says
Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen said the war in Ukraine has triggered higher food and energy prices around the world, and described the globe’s economic outlook as “challenging” and “uncertain.”
“The United States in many ways is best positioned I think to meet this challenge given the strength of our labor market and the economy,” Yellen said ahead of a meeting of the G-7 finance ministers and central bank governors in Bonn, Germany.
Yellen, who spent the week in Warsaw and Brussels, added that rising inflation also poses a significant challenge to the global economy.
She said that the sweeping global sanctions imposed on Russia by the U.S. and more than 30 countries are curbing the Kremlin’s ability to finance its ongoing war in Ukraine.
“Russia is experiencing a recession, high inflation, acute challenges in their financial system and an inability to procure materials and products they need to support their war and their economy,” she said, adding that two Russian tank manufacturers recently shut down due to a lack of supplies.
— Amanda Macias
Russian soldier admits killing unarmed Ukrainian in first war crimes trial
A district court in Kyiv has begun its first war crimes trial involving a Russian soldier who was a part of Russia’s invading forces.
Vadim Shishimarin, a 21-year-old Russian tank commander held in Ukraine, is charged with murdering a 62-year-old civilian in the northeast Ukrainian village of Chupakhivka on Feb. 28. He told the court that he pleaded guilty, Reuters reported Wednesday.
Shishimarin could face a life sentence if convicted.
Ukraine has accused Russia of various war crimes during the three-month conflict with Russia. Investigations and evidence is being gathered to support those claims, against a backdrop of a very live conflict.
For its part, Russia has denied targeting civilians or civilian infrastructure, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary. Early on in the conflict, Russia shelled a maternity hospital as well as a theater where hundreds of civilians were sheltering, for example.
Ukrainian state prosecutors have said the soldier and four other servicemen drove into the village of Chupakhivka where they saw an unarmed resident riding a bicycle and talking on his phone.
They said Shishimarin was ordered by another serviceman to kill the civilian to prevent him reporting on the Russians’ presence and fired several shots through the open window of the car with an assault rifle at the civilian’s head. The civilian died on the spot.
— Reuters
Former Finnish PM: Russia doesn’t see Finland and Sweden NATO accession as a threat
Russia doesn’t actually see Finland and Sweden’s accession to the NATO alliance as a military threat, Former Finnish Prime Minister Alexander Stubb told CNBC, despite its warnings against any enlargement of the organization.
“[The] Russian reaction, actually it has been quite moderate, and I think the reason is quite clear,” Stubb said. “Russia does not see Finnish and Swedish accession to NATO as a military threat or security threat. That was also said by Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov yesterday,” he said. “And it is because the profile that Sweden and Finland are going to take inside NATO is going to be a Nordic profile.”
The former prime minister noted that three Nordic states — Iceland, Norway and Denmark — have been members of the alliance since 1949. While Finland and Sweden have been historically “nonaligned,” they were not neutral, and have been allied partners of NATO since the mid-1990s, engaging in joint military exercises with NATO members.
“So with that profile I think the Kremlin has already counted Sweden and Finland as members of the alliance, even though we were not members and not under Article 5, the security guarantee collective defense umbrella. So I think the reaction was moderate and will continue to be moderate. This is not an aggressive enlargement.”
Indeed, despite weeks of threatening “consequences” if the two countries joined NATO — which with Finland’s 830-mile shared border with Russia would double the size of the NATO-Russia border — Putin has softened his tone, saying earlier this week that Moscow does not have problems with either country and that they are not a threat to Russia.
Stubb then made a final point: “We do not join NATO against anyone. We join it for ourselves. For us, foreign security policy is not a zero-sum game.”
— Natasha Turak
As inflation slows, Russia is hoping to avoid a financial crisis
Russia believes it has swerved a financial crisis as the ruble rallies and economic data improves, but strategists say the numbers mask some ugly truths for Moscow.
Although still running hot, recent inflation figures have shown a sharp slowdown in monthly price increases, while the ruble has gone from an all-time low in March to the world’s best-performing currency this year.
Economic activity indicators have improved, and Russia has thus far avoided defaulting on its foreign currency debt, despite Western sanctions freezing large swathes of its reserves.However, economists have cautioned that the exceptional measures taken by the Kremlin and the Central Bank of Russia to safeguard the currency have resulted in synthetic strength that could unravel if circumstances change.
Photos show members of Azov battalion after apparent surrender in Mariupol
Photos below show servicemen of Ukraine’s national battalion “Azov,” which is an all-volunteer infantry military unit, being transferred to Yelenovka in Mariupol. The Azov Battalion is part of the Ukrainian National Guard, but also has historical links to neo-Nazis.
Ukraine has avoided using the word “surrendered” when referencing what it has called the “evacuation” of its soldiers who have been in the Azovstal steelworks for weeks. Ukraine has said that several hundred soldiers have been evacuated, it has not said how many people are left within the complex, however. In addition, the fate of the evacuees remains uncertain although a prisoner exchange appeared to be an option.
Russia’s Ministry of Defence has claimed that almost a thousand Ukrainian soldiers who were holed up in the steelworks complex in the besieged city of Mariupol have “surrendered.” Over the past day, the ministry said in an update Wednesday, “a total of 959 militants have surrendered … including 80 wounded.” Of those, it said 51 needed inpatient treatment and were placed in the hospital of Novoazovsk of the Donetsk People’s Republic, a pro-Russian region of the Donbas.
—Anadolu Agency | Getty Images
Russian military analyst gives damning assessment of Ukraine war on state TV
In a country where independent media and commentary has all but disappeared from public view, it’s rare to hear dissenting voices on the many state-controlled TV networks in Russia — particularly now with the country at war with Ukraine.
But one well-known military analyst and veteran has stood out this week after he appeared on state TV and gave a damning assessment of the Ukraine invasion, or what Russia calls its “special military operation.”
“The situation, frankly speaking, will get worse for us,” Mikhail Khodaryonok, a retired Russian army colonel, told the “60 Minutes” talk show on Rossiya-1 TV program hosted by Olga Skabeyeva, who’s renowned for her pro-Kremlin stance.
A penal colony is used for exiled prisoners, who are separated them from the general population and isolated in a remote location.
Buses carrying an unknown number of Ukrainian soldiers from the Mariupol steel plant were also seen arriving at another former penal colony near Olenivka, the Associated Press said.
Ukrainian official Lyudmyla Denisova said most civilians are held for a month, but those considered “particularly unreliable” — like former soldiers and police — are held for two months, according to an AP report.
Among those held were about 30 volunteers who delivered humanitarian aid to Mariupol while it was under Russian siege, Denisova said, according to the AP.
— Chelsea Ong
Finland and Sweden formally apply to join NATO
Finland and Sweden formally applied to join the NATO alliance on Wednesday, setting in motion an accession process that is expected to take only a few weeks.
Still, an approval of their applications by all 30 current NATO members, with some of them requiring approval from their parliaments, could take up to a year.
There is broad approval of the Nordic nations joining the Western military alliance with Turkey the only country to voice strong objections so far.
Finland’s Mission to NATO tweeted that it was a “historic day.”
— Holly Ellyatt
U.S. and Turkey officials to meet with NATO expansion on the agenda
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken is to meet Turkey’s Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu in New York on Wednesday amid tensions among NATO members following Ankara’s objections to Finland and Sweden’s bids to join the Western military alliance.
Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has voiced strong opposition to the bids and have said neither country should “bother” to send delegations to Ankara to try to persuade Turkey to approve their membership applications. NATO requires a consensus among all its current 30 members for the countries to be able to join.
Briefing the press on the forthcoming meeting, U.S. State Dept. spokesman Ned Price refused to comment on Erdogan’s comments, or on what the meeting might entail, but said “there is strong consensus there has been strong consensus for admitting Finland and Sweden” among NATO allies.
“We are confident we’ll be able to preserve that consensus,” Price said.
— Holly Ellyatt
Russia targeting military and civilian targets throughout Ukraine, army says
In their latest military update, Ukraine’s forces say that Russia is continuing to launch missile strikes at military and civilian targets in Ukraine.
Ukraine said the Russian forces’ “main focus is on maintaining previously occupied frontiers, conducting reconnaissance, engineering equipment positions, replenishing stocks, and trying to improve its tactical position” adding that they “continue to launch missile strikes on military and civilian targets throughout Ukraine.”
The fate of the southern port city Mariupol is uncertain but is likely to come under complete Russian control soon, as Ukraine looks to evacuate the remaining forces from the Azovstal steelworks.
In its latest update, Ukraine’s General Staff of the Armed Forces said Russia was “blocking” Ukrainian units near the plant, and “continues to inflict artillery and air strikes.”
Meanwhile, Ukraine’s forces said 12 enemy attacks had been repelled in the Donetsk and Luhansk areas over the past 24 hours, with three Russian tanks, three artillery systems, six units of armored combat vehicles and seven enemy vehicles destroyed.
— Holly Ellyatt
Ukraine says Russia’s army has lost 27,900 soldiers since the war started
The Russian army has lost 27,900 soldiers since its invasion of Ukraine on Feb. 24, the Ukrainian Defense Ministry said in a video on Telegram, NBC News reported.
Last week, Ukraine announced that 501 members of its National Guard had died since the invasion started, NBC News reported. The National Guard serves as a military unit with law enforcement powers and was formed in 2014 when Russia annexed the Black Sea peninsula of Crimea.
— Chelsea Ong
Turkey will not block Sweden and Finland NATO membership requests: Luxembourg foreign minister
Luxembourg’s foreign minister says he does not believe Turkey will block Sweden’s and Finland’s NATO membership bids despite the Turkish president’s objections, the Associated Press reported.
Sweden and Finland are submitting their membership applications to the alliance as Russia’s invasion of Ukraine continues. But all 30 NATO member countries, among them Turkey, must agree to let these countries join.
However, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has said he opposes the two countries joining NATO, referencing the hosting of members of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party, which Turkey classifies as a terrorist group.
Nonetheless, Luxembourg’s foreign minister, Jean Asselborn, told Germany’s Deutschlandfunk radio he suspects Erdogan is “pushing up the price” for the countries to join the alliance, the Associated Press reported.
“At the end of the day, I am convinced that Turkey can’t slam the brakes on this,” Asselborn said, according to the Associated Press.
— Chelsea Ong
U.S. Senate advances nearly $40 billion Ukraine aid bill
The U.S. Senate advanced a nearly $40 billion aid package for Ukraine.
The chamber voted to move ahead with the bill by an 88-11 margin. All of the senators who opposed the measure were Republicans.
A final vote on the military and humanitarian assistance could take place as soon as Thursday. Once the Senate passes the bill, it will head to President Joe Biden’s desk for his signature.
Senate leaders wanted to approve the bill quickly last week, but Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., blocked the unanimous consent needed to pass it.
— Jacob Pramuk
Amnesty International raises concerns following reports Ukrainian troops surrendered at Azovstal plant
Amnesty International raised concerns following reports that Ukrainian forces holed up in Mariupol’s Azovstal steel plant surrendered to Russia’s armed forces.
“Amnesty International has documented summary killings of captives by Russia-backed separatist forces in eastern Ukraine, as well as the extrajudicial executions of Ukrainian civilians by Russian forces in recent weeks. The Azov Battalion soldiers who surrendered today must not meet the same fate,” wrote Denis Krivosheev, Amnesty International’s deputy director for Eastern Europe and Central Asia.
Krivosheev added that prisoners of war should have immediate access to medical treatment and should not be subjected to “any form of torture or ill-treatment.”
“The relevant authorities must fully respect the rights of prisoners of war in accordance with the Geneva conventions,” he said, referencing international humanitarian law.
Trump threw the embattled congressman a lifeline ahead of his Tuesday primary, posting on Truth Social — Trump’s social media platform — an appeal for voters to “give Madison a second chance.” In his post, Trump wrote that Cawthorn had recently “made some foolish mistakes, which I don’t believe he’ll make again.”
“My record is unparalleled, my endorsements, it’s totally unparalleled. Nobody’s ever had a record like this. I’m almost unblemished,” Trump said during an interview with David Brody on the Christian Broadcasting Network’s show “The 700 Club.”
Trump said on the show that Republicans should be afraid of him if their views didn’t line up with his. “Because if I endorsed them, they win, and if I don’t endorse them, they don’t win. I mean, that’s almost 100% of the case,” the former President said.
A Trump-backed GOP win is certainly not guaranteed if this week’s results are anything to go by. Another Trump-endorsed political candidate, Charles Herbster, lost his gubernatorial race in Nebraska last week amid allegations of sexual assault from eight women.
Tina Kotek speaks during Day 1 of the Democratic National Convention at the Wells Fargo Center in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, July 25, 2016. On Tuesday, she won Oregon’s gubernatorial Democratic primary. If she wins in November, Kotek will be the nation’s first openly lesbian governor.
ROBYN BECK/AFP via Getty Images
hide caption
toggle caption
ROBYN BECK/AFP via Getty Images
Tina Kotek speaks during Day 1 of the Democratic National Convention at the Wells Fargo Center in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, July 25, 2016. On Tuesday, she won Oregon’s gubernatorial Democratic primary. If she wins in November, Kotek will be the nation’s first openly lesbian governor.
ROBYN BECK/AFP via Getty Images
Tina Kotek is on the precipice of making history following her win in Oregon’s Democratic gubernatorial primary Tuesday.
“This will be a three-way race for the highest office in our state, and this will be an election unlike anything any of us have ever seen,” she told supporters during her acceptance speech, Oregon Public Broadcasting reported.
If she wins the general election in November, Kotek, who is formerly the state’s longest-serving speaker of the House as well as the first openly lesbian speaker in the nation, she will become the first openly lesbian governor in the United States. If elected, she told the Human Rights Campaign that she promises to continue her career-long work “to protect and lift up LGBTQ+ Oregonians.”
Kotek’s win comes at a time when more candidates running for office identify as LGBTQ. More than 600 LGBTQ candidates are on ballots this year, according to the LGBTQ Victory Fund, a nonpartisan political action committee that supports candidates running for office.
The Fund also says more LGBTQ people are running for Congress in 2022 than ever before.
“At least 101 people ran or are running for the U.S. Senate or U.S. House – with 96 still actively running as of February 21, 2022. That marks a 16.1 percent increase in LGBTQ Congressional candidates compared to the 2020 election cycle, when 87 people ran,” the Fund’s website reads.
Many candidates have cited the rash of anti-LGBTQ legislation passed by state houses in recent years as what prompted them to seek office.
“I’m running because [Montana] passed some of the most discriminatory bills we’ve had, you know, ever in the state of Montana,” Jacob Torgerson, a gay man running for his state’s House of Representatives, told NPR.
The iconic steel plant that served as the last holdout in Ukraine’s ill-fated struggle to keep Russian troops from conquering the city will be torn down, a separatist leader said Tuesday.
Denis Pushilin, head of the Russia-backed Donetsk People’s Republic, told the Donetsk News Agency the Azovstal plant – four square miles of bunkers, tunnels and industrial space – will be transformed into a park or a technology commercial park.
Pushilin said about 60% of all buildings in Mariupol have been destroyed. The ruined buildings will be demolished and replaced, he said, and the city will be rebuilt as a resort city with Russian aid.
The complete fall of Mariupol to the Russians appeared imminent early Wednesday. The Russian Defense Ministry said 959 holdout soldiers had surrendered since Monday. Pushilin, however, said top commanders in the plan had not yet emerged.
“No matter what emotions some people might feel, and I know that opinions differ, if the enemy laid down arms, his further fate is decided by a court,” Pushilin said during his visit to Mariupol.” If it’s a (Nazi) criminal, it’s a tribunal.”
►Russia is holding over 3,000 civilians from Mariupol in the Donetsk region of eastern Ukraine, Ukraine’s human rights ombudsman said.
►Ukrainian guerrilla fighters reportedly have killed several high-ranking Russian officers in the southern city of Melitopol, the regional administration said on Telegram.
►Eight civilians were killed in Russian attacks on 45 settlements in the Donetsk and Luhansk regions, the General Staff of the Ukrainian Armed Forces said.
►Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said Russian forces also fired missiles at the western Lviv region and the Sumy and Chernihiv regions in the northeast. He said the border regions of Ukraine saw Russian “sabotage activity.”
Finland, Sweden formally apply for NATO membership
Finland and Sweden have formally applied to join NATO, a move driven by security concerns over Russia’s war in Ukraine. The application must now be weighed by the 30 member countries and all must agree for membership to be approved. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has expressed reservations about Finland and Sweden joining. If those objections can be worked out, expedited membership could be granted within a few months.
“I warmly welcome the requests by Finland and Sweden to join NATO. You are our closest partners,” NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg said Wednesday after a receiving application letters from the two Nordic countries’ ambassadors.
US pushing for regular contact with Brittney Griner, detained WNBA star
The U.S. has yet to establish regular contact with Brittney Griner, the WNBA star who has been detained in Russia for almost three months.
Griner, who plays for the Phoenix Mercury, has been detained – wrongfully, the Biden administration says – in Russia since February after marijuana was allegedly found in her luggage at a Moscow airport.
The 31-year-old faces drug smuggling charges that carry a maximum penalty of 10 years in prison.
Last week, her pre-trial detention in Russia was extended for a month – at that point, an American consular official was able to meet with Griner.
WASHINGTON, May 17 (Reuters) – Investigators looking into the crash of a China Eastern Airlines (600115.SS) jet are examining the actions of the crew on the flight deck, with no evidence found of a technical malfunction, two people briefed on the matter said.
In mainland China’s deadliest aviation disaster for 28 years, the Boeing 737-800 crashed in the mountains of southern Guangxi on March 21, after a sudden plunge from cruising altitude, killing all 123 passengers and nine crew. read more
The pilots did not respond to repeated calls from air traffic controllers and nearby planes during the rapid descent, authorities have said.
On Tuesday, the Wall Street Journal said flight data from one of the black boxes indicated that someone in the cockpit intentionally crashed the plane, citing people familiar with the preliminary assessment of U.S. officials.
One source told Reuters that investigators were looking at whether the crash was a “voluntary” act involving crew inputs to the controls, though that does not necessarily mean the dive was intentional.
The cockpit voice recorder was damaged during the crash and it is unclear whether investigators have been able to retrieve any information from it.
Boeing Co (BA.N), the maker of the jet, and the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) declined to comment and referred questions to Chinese regulators.
The Civil Aviation Administration of China (CAAC), which is leading the investigation, did not respond immediately to a request for comment.
Screenshots of the Wall Street Journal story appeared to have been censored both on China’s Weibo social media platform and the Wechat messaging app on Wednesday.
The hashtag topics “China Eastern” and “China Eastern black boxes” are banned on Weibo, which cited a breach of laws, and users are unable to share posts on the incident in Wechat groups.
In an April 11 response to internet rumors of a deliberate crash, the CAAC said the speculation had “gravely misled the public” and “interfered with the accident investigation work”.
On Wednesday, a woman who had lost her husband in the crash, asked to be identified only by her surname, Wen, said she had not seen the Wall Street Journal report but hoped the results of the investigation would be released soon.
Wen added that she and other members of victims’ families had signed an agreement with China Eastern that included a clause on compensation, but declined to say how much was offered.
China Eastern did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
1/2
Rescue workers work at the site where a China Eastern Airlines Boeing 737-800 plane flying from Kunming to Guangzhou crashed, in Wuzhou, Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, China March 24, 2022. REUTERS/Carlos Garcia Rawlins/File Photo
The Wall Street Journal said the airline had said in a statement that no evidence had emerged that could determine if there were any problems with the aircraft.
NO TECHNICAL RECOMMENDATIONS
The 737-800 is a widely flown predecessor to Boeing’s 737 MAX but lacks the systems linked to fatal 737-MAX crashes in 2018 and 2019 that brought a lengthy grounding of the MAX.
China Eastern grounded its entire fleet of 737-800 planes after the crash but resumed flights in mid-April, a decision widely seen at the time as ruling out any immediate new safety concerns over Boeing’s most widely used model.
In a summary of an unpublished preliminary crash report last month, Chinese investigators did not point to any technical recommendations for the 737-800, which has been in service since 1997 with a strong safety record, according to experts.
In a May 10 interview with Reuters, NTSB Chair Jennifer Homendy said board investigators and Boeing had traveled to China to assist the Chinese investigation, which had not found any safety issues requiring urgent action.
Homendy said if the board had any safety concerns it would “issue urgent safety recommendations.”
The NTSB assisted Chinese investigators with the review of black boxes at its U.S. laboratory in Washington at China’s request, despite political tension between the countries.
CAAC said the NTSB confirmed that it did not release information about the China Eastern crash to media, the state-owned Global Times said.
Shares of Boeing closed up 6.5%.
A final report into the causes of the crash could take two years or more to compile, Chinese officials have said. Analysts blame most crashes on a cocktail of human and technical factors.
Deliberate crashes are exceptionally rare globally.
In March 2015, a Germanwings co-pilot deliberately flew an Airbus A320 into a French mountainside, killing all 150 on board.
French investigators found the 27-year-old was suffering from a suspected “psychotic depressive episode,” concealed from his employer. They later called for better mental health guidelines and stronger peer support groups for pilots.
“God is good, all the time,” Mr. Mastriano said in his victory speech, outlining “day one” goals that included “mandates are gone,” “any jab for job requirements are gone,” critical race theory is “over,” “only biological females can play on biological female teams” and “you can only use the bathroom that your biological anatomy says.”
The Republican Governors Association issued a tepid response after the race was called, not promising financial support. “The R.G.A. remains committed to engaging in competitive gubernatorial contests,” the group’s executive director, Dave Rexrode, said in a statement.
In the Senate race, the celebrity physician Dr. Mehmet Oz and David McCormick, the former chief executive of the world’s largest hedge fund, had bludgeoned each other on the airwaves and on the campaign trail for months in the Republican primary. With more than 90 percent of the vote counted, they were knotted together — and possibly within range of a recount, which is triggered under state law if the margin is 0.5 percent or less of the total vote.
Both Mr. McCormick and Dr. Oz said in speeches to supporters that there would be no immediate result.
“We have tens of thousands of mail-in ballots that have not been counted,” Mr. McCormick told the crowd at his election night watch party in Pittsburgh late Tuesday night, leaving unsaid that top Republicans have systematically sought to undermine faith in such ballots since 2020.
Kathy Barnette, a far-right commentator who has a history of expressing homophobic and anti-Muslim views, made a surprising late surge on the strength of her compelling personal story but was further behind.
In a sign of the race’s importance this fall, President Biden congratulated the Democratic nominee, Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, and said of the G.O.P. field that “whoever emerges will be too dangerous, too craven, and too extreme.”
Mr. Mastriano’s victory sets up a fall clash with Attorney General Josh Shapiro, who was unopposed in the Democratic primary, a matchup with vast potential consequences both for state-level issues like abortion rights and for election certification in the 2024 presidential race.
Pennsylvania Republicans who fully control the Legislature are likely to attempt to restrict abortion rights if the Supreme Court overturns Roe v. Wade, as expected. That means whoever occupies the governor’s residence in Harrisburg would determine whether such a bill becomes law. And the Pennsylvania governor appoints the secretary of state, whose office will oversee the 2024 election.
Mr. Mastriano and Ms. Barnette formed something of a hard-right ticket, endorsing one another as they attempted to fend off their better-funded rivals. Dr. Oz relied heavily on the conservative credibility he gained from Mr. Trump’s endorsement while Mr. McCormick’s Wall Street allies flooded the airwaves with attack ads.
Five states — Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Kentucky, Oregon and Idaho — held primaries on Tuesday, with the outcomes signaling the relative strength of the ideological factions in both political parties.
In North Carolina, Representative Madison Cawthorn, a Trump-backed Republican who has created a string of controversies and mini-scandals, including his comment that some colleagues in Washington had indulged in cocaine and orgies, conceded defeat to his primary challenger on Tuesday night, State Senator Chuck Edwards. He became the first incumbent who was not facing another member of Congress to lose a primary in 2022.
Also in North Carolina, Representative Ted Budd handily won the Republican nomination for an open Senate seat, riding an early Trump endorsement and millions of dollars in outside spending to best former Gov. Pat McCrory, in another sign of the diminished standing of the party establishment. Mr. Budd will face Cheri Beasley, a Democrat who is a former chief justice of the State Supreme Court and who would become North Carolina’s first Black senator if elected.
In Idaho, another Trump-backed candidate, Lt. Gov. Janice McGeachin, lost her challenge to Gov. Brad Little, a fellow Republican. And in Oregon, Representative Kurt Schrader, a top moderate Democrat, was trailing his progressive challenger, Jamie McLeod-Skinner, in early vote tallies.
But Pennsylvania was the center of attention, a perennial presidential battleground that is seen as a bellwether of the nation’s political mood. The retirement of Senator Pat Toomey, a Republican, and term limits for Gov. Tom Wolf, a Democrat, meant rare simultaneous open races for both governor and Senate — and the latter could tip control of a chamber now evenly split 50-50 between the two parties.
Mr. Mastriano’s election denialism has been a key part of his appeal to the Republican base. Pennsylvania is one of three top presidential battlegrounds with a current Democratic governorship up for grabs in 2022 and a Republican-led Legislature that has promoted voter-fraud myths. The two other states are Michigan and Wisconsin.
In the Pennsylvania Senate race, Mr. Fetterman, whose progressivism and campaign-trail uniform of shorts and hoodies helped earn him the support of grass-roots voters and a passionate online donor base, won the Democratic primary, easily defeating Representative Conor Lamb, a moderate from outside Pittsburgh who was endorsed by Democratic officials statewide as the most electable candidate.
Mr. Fetterman was leading in every county in the state.
The Democratic primaries came to an unusual finish, with both leading candidates absent from the trail. Mr. Shapiro, 48, tested positive for the coronavirus and was isolating at home while Mr. Fetterman, 52, suffered a stroke on Friday and his campaign announced he had a procedure on Tuesday “to implant a pacemaker with a defibrillator.”
Both Democrats cast emergency absentee ballots.
Pennsylvania is outwardly a swing state, but Democratic strength has eroded in recent years. That has been clear in the difference between former President Barack Obama’s five-point victory in 2012 in the state and the much narrower, one-point presidential races in 2016 and 2020. Democrats, who have long led in party registrations, have seen their advantage slip to 550,000, down from 815,000 during the May 2018 primaries.
Whomever Mr. Fetterman faces, the Pennsylvania Senate race is expected to be among the fiercest and most expensive of the fall, with millions of dollars in television ads already reserved.
A hulking figure with a shaved head, tattoos and a goatee, Mr. Fetterman has cultivated an outsider image in part by refusing to court elected party officials and campaigning in rural counties where Democrats have suffered huge losses. When he met President Biden at the site of a collapsed bridge, he wore shorts. When he attended the White House Easter Egg Roll, he sported a sweatshirt.
Democratic voters embraced that style and Mr. Fetterman’s promise to win back support in the state’s conservative interior counties over the centrist polish of Mr. Lamb, as well as Malcolm Kenyatta, a liberal state legislator from the Philadelphia area.
“He looks like a gruff working-class Western Pennsylvania dude,’’ Brendan McPhillips, who ran Mr. Biden’s campaign in the state in 2020, said of Mr. Fetterman. “When he walks into a local dive bar, there’s a resonance there.”
Mr. Fetterman, who endorsed Senator Bernie Sanders’ presidential campaign in 2016, ran for Senate that same year, finishing a distant third in the primary.
The political climate nationally for Democrats in 2022 looks bleak. But many Pennsylvania Republicans are still openly worried about their party’s chances with a Mastriano-led ticket.
Mr. Mastriano, who has been subpoenaed by the congressional committee investigating the Jan. 6 riot, made his own failed effort to subpoena voting machines to “audit” the 2020 election. Last month he spoke at a conference organized by QAnon conspiracy theorists.
“He’s very far right,” said Tom Marino, a former Republican congressman in the state. “There will be moderate Republicans and independents and perhaps even some moderate Democrats in Pennsylvania that will not vote for Mastriano.”
Last-minute efforts to consolidate a deeply splintered Republican field and unite behind the leading Mastriano alternative in the polls, former Representative Lou Barletta, had mostly flopped even before Mr. Trump issued his endorsement. Mr. Mastriano was leading in a landslide, roughly doubling Mr. Barletta’s vote total.
Mr. Marino lashed out at Mr. Trump for not backing Mr. Barletta. Both Mr. Marino and Mr. Barletta had supported Mr. Trump in 2016. Mr. Marino said he was frustrated that the former president would spurn an early Trump supporter in favor of Mr. Mastriano. “With Trump, loyalty is a one-way street,” Mr. Marino said in an interview, “and I’ve learned that now.”
Mr. Shapiro made clear his preference, meddling in the Republican primary in the final weeks to boost Mr. Mastriano, an Army veteran who served in Iraq and Afghanistan, by running television ads that highlighted some of his conservative stances popular with the Republican base.
As of May 2, the Shapiro campaign had $15.8 million; the Mastriano campaign had less than $800,000, according to state records.
Mr. Shapiro has said he will make the fall election partly a referendum on abortion rights, given the likelihood that, in a post-Roe world, the Republican-led legislature will pass a bill strongly restricting abortion. Mr. Shapiro has said he would veto such a measure while Mr. Mastriano, who has made his Christian faith central to his candidacy, favors banning abortion with no exceptions for rape, incest or the mother’s health.
For much of 2022, the Republican Senate primary had been dominated by Dr. Oz and Mr. McCormick, who spent, along with allies, more than $45 million on television advertisements. Ms. Barnette spent less than $200,000 but used debates and her biography as a Black woman who was a “byproduct of rape” and who became an unabashed right-wing Republican to connect with the conservative base.
The Club for Growth, an anti-tax group, spent more than $2 million to give Ms. Barnette a late boost but an intense set of last-minute attacks, including from Mr. Trump, appeared to take a toll. “When she’s vetted, it’s going to be a catastrophe for the party,’’ the former president warned Monday.
She has notably not committed to backing her G.O.P. rivals in November. “I have no intention of supporting globalists,” she said on a Breitbart podcast on Monday.
Mr. Trump had originally endorsed Sean Parnell, a failed congressional candidate, for the seat last year, but Mr. Parnell quit the race after his estranged wife accused him of abuse. In April, Mr. Trump endorsed Dr. Oz after a heavy lobbying campaign by both Mr. McCormick, who served in the George W. Bush administration, and Dr. Oz.
A key figure in Dr. Oz’s camp was Sean Hannity, the Fox News host who regularly had the doctor on his program.
In his election night speech, Dr. Oz thanked, in order, his wife, Mr. Trump and Mr. Hannity. “He understands exactly how to make a difference and he’s been doing that this entire campaign,” Dr. Oz said of Mr. Hannity.
Mr. McCormick, whose wife was a senior Trump White House official, brought a bevy of Trump alumni onto his campaign team — a fact that Mr. Trump ridiculed at his lone rally with Dr. Oz.
“If anybody was within 200 miles of me, he hired them,” Mr. Trump said of Mr. McCormick.
Both Mr. McCormick and Dr. Oz were accused of carpetbagging. Mr. McCormick, who is from Pennsylvania, lived in Connecticut while leading Bridgewater, the hedge fund. Dr. Oz, who attended medical school at the University of Pennsylvania, moved back to the state from New Jersey in late 2020, according to his campaign, originally renting a home from his wife’s parents.
Dr. Oz faced hesitancy from conservative voters about his residency, his dual Turkish citizenship and previous positions that he took in interviews, on his TV show and in columns with his byline for gun restrictions and abortion rights. Those issues — along with the image of him kissing his Hollywood star — were aired relentlessly by a pro-McCormick super PAC.
Mr. Trump, who traveled to the state to hold a rally for Dr. Oz, was instrumental in building up the right-wing bona fides. At a rally on the eve of the election, Dr. Oz put Mr. Trump on speakerphone and held it close to the microphone, nodding along as the former president said, “He’s a loyal MAGA person.”
Nick Corasaniti and Jazmine Ulloa contributed reporting.
BRUSSELS, May 18 (Reuters) – Finland and Sweden formally applied to join the NATO alliance on Wednesday at allied headquarters, a decision spurred by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, but face objections from Turkey to an accession process that is expected to take only a few weeks.
Neutral throughout the Cold War, Sweden’s and Finland’s decision to join NATO is one of the most significant changes in Europe’s security architecture for decades, reflecting a sweeping shift in public opinion in the Nordic region since Russia’s Feb. 24 invasion.
“This is a historic moment, which we must seize,” NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg said at a short ceremony in which the Swedish and Finnish ambassadors to the alliance handed over their application letters, each in a white folder embossed with their national flag.
“I warmly welcome requests by Finland and Sweden to join NATO. You are our closest partners, and your membership in NATO will increase our shared security,” Stoltenberg said. The alliance considers that the accession of Finland and Sweden would hugely strengthen it in the Baltic Sea.
With the applications formally submitted, the Nordic countries and their many backers now face uncertain months where any resistance to their bids needs to be overcome, with all 30 of NATO’s members needing to approve the enlargement.
Ratification by all allied parliaments could take up to a year, diplomats say.
Turkey has surprised its allies in recent days by saying it had reservations about Finnish and Swedish membership, saying the two countries harbour individuals linked to groups it deems terrorists and hitting out at arms export embargoes imposed on it after its Syria incursion in 2019. read more
1/5
Finland’s Ambassador to NATO Klaus Korhonen, NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg and Sweden’s Ambassador to NATO Axel Wernhoff attend a ceremony to mark Sweden’s and Finland’s application for membership in Brussels, Belgium, May 18, 2022. REUTERS/Johanna Geron/Pool
Stoltenberg said on Wednesday that he thought the issues could be resolved.
“We are determined to work through all issues and reach rapid conclusions,” Stoltenberg said, noting strong support from all other allies.
Seeking to move the membership process along, Sweden’s defence minister has already headed to Washington and will be followed by Swedish Prime Minister Magdalena Andersson and Finnish President Sauli Niinisto later this week. read more
The countries hope speedy ratification by the United States, the alliance’s premier power, will help smooth their path to membership with the White House having said it is confident any obstacles can be overcome. read more
The decision to seek a place under the NATO umbrella represents a setback for Moscow, with the war in Ukraine triggering the very kind of enlargement of the alliance on Russia’s borders that it took to arms to prevent.
So far, Moscow’s response has been unexpectedly muted, having previously warned of steps of a “military-technical” nature and that it could deploy nuclear weapons in its European exclave of Kaliningrad were the countries to join.
President Vladimir Putin said on Monday that Swedish and Finnish NATO membership posed no threat to Russia, but cautioned that Moscow would respond if the Western alliance boosted military infrastructure in the new Nordic members. read more
A contingent of Ukrainian fighters who doggedly defended a steel mill in Mariupol for weeks “fulfilled its combat mission,” Ukrainian officials said, and efforts were underway Tuesday to evacuate the last of the group.
“The Supreme Military Command ordered the commanders of the units stationed at Azovstal to save the lives of their personnel,” the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine said in a statement. “Mariupol defenders are heroes of our time.”
More than 260 Ukrainian troops were evacuated to areas controlled by Russian-backed separatists. The Kremlin called the exodus a mass surrender. Russian Defense Ministry video shows troops patting down and searching the fighters. Some were on stretchers as they were loaded onto the buses.
Ukraine Minister for the Reintegration Irina Vereshchuk said a prisoner exchange will take place for the more than 50 wounded soldiers, when their condition stabilizes, along with more than 200 other fighters evacuated through a humanitarian corridor. Hundreds of prisoners from both sides have been exchanged since the war began Feb. 24.
An unknown number of troops remained at the Azovstal steel plant that sprawls across 4 square miles. The plant has symbolized Ukraine’s final holdout in the besieged city.
“The work to bring the guys home continues, and it requires delicacy and time,” Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said.
►Seven civilians were killed in Ukraine’s eastern Donetsk region as a result of Russian attacks, Ukrainian regional governor Pavlo Kyrylenko posted Tuesday on Telegram. Another six people were injured.
►French President Emmanuel Macron committed to increasing weapons shipments in a phone conversation Tuesday with his Ukrainian counterpart Volodymyr Zelenskyy, France24.com reported.
►No negotiations between the Russian and Ukrainian delegations are being conducted because “Ukraine has in fact quit the process of negotiations,” Russia’s Deputy Foreign Minister Andrey Rudenko said Tuesday. Ukraine presidential adviser Mykhailo Podolyak blamed Moscow for taking an “all or nothing” approach to the talks.
►Russia’s prosecutor general has asked his nation’s Supreme Court to recognize Ukraine’s Azov Regiment as a terrorist organization. Interfax news agency said the court will hear the case May 26. The volunteer militia has been fighting pro-Russian separatists in Ukraine since 2014, and its fighters drew global attention for their desperate stand in the Azovstal steel plant in Mariupol.
►Finland’s Eduskunta legislature voted 188-8 Tuesday to approve Finland seeking NATO membership. The vote was a formality as Finnish President Sauli Niinisto and Prime Minister Sanna Marin announced Sunday the intention to join the alliance.
Zelenskyy urges speaking out against war at Cannes Film Festival
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, a former actor, has a flair for the dramatic. He demonstrated that trait again Tuesday when he made a video appearance at the opening ceremony of the Cannes Film Festival in France.
If Zelenskyy’s presence was surprising, his words were powerful, prompting the audience at the Palais des Festivals to give him a standing ovation, according to France24.com.
“Hundreds of people are dying every day. They won’t get up again after the clapping at the end,” Zelenskyy said in the prerecorded message. “Will cinema keep quiet, or will it speak up?”
Zelenskyy alluded to the 1940 film “The Great Dictator,” featuring Charlie Chaplin playing the two leading roles. Released during World War II, the movie satirizes Nazi leader Adolf Hitler.
“Chaplin’s dictator did not destroy the real dictator, but thanks to cinema, thanks to this film, cinema did not stay quiet,” Zelenskyy said. “We need a new Chaplin to prove today that cinema is not mute.”
Treasury Secretary Yellen says war should hasten transition to clean energy
The energy security emergency facing Europe and the world because of the war is a moment to rapidly accelerate the transition to clean energy, Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen said Tuesday. Yellen, in a prepared speech for the Brussels Economic Forum, called the war a “wake-up call” for energy security and said that “no country controls the wind and the sun.” Europe’s dependence on Russian energy has complicated efforts to sting Moscow with harsh economic sanctions.
“Let’s make sure that this is the last time that the global economy is held hostage to the hostile actions of those who produce fossil fuels,” Yellen said. “This will happen again if we don’t change our approach.”
International court sends 42 experts to Ukraine for war crimes probe
The chief prosecutor for the International Criminal Court said Tuesday that he has deployed a team of 42 investigators, forensic experts and support personnel to Ukraine. Prosecutor Karim Khan said the team, working with the Ukrainian authorities, will connect crime scene investigations and strengthen “hard evidence.”
To be classified as crimes against humanity, attacks have to be part of what the ICC’s founding treaty calls “a widespread or systematic attack directed against any civilian population.” Thousands of Ukrainian civilians are believed to have died since the Russian invasion began less than three months ago.
“It is essential that we demonstrate to survivors and the families of victims that international law is relevant,” Khan said in a statement, pledging to ” bring them some measure of solace through the process of justice.”
$40B funding for Ukraine nears approval
Congress is poised to approve more than $40 billion in emergency funding to support Ukraine, an amount nearly three times greater than what the U.S. has already committed in military, humanitarian and other assistance to beat back Russia’s invasion.
Along with the $13.6 billion passed in March, the combined $53.7 billion is about 81% of Russia’s 2021 defense budget, and more than one-quarter the size of Ukraine’s pre-war economy. The funding does not include the cost of reconstruction, which has been estimated at $600 billion. Paul Stephan, a University of Virginia law school professor who has worked at the State and Defense departments, was wary of proposals to use frozen Russian assets for rebuilding Ukraine.
“Russia will not always be a pariah,” Stephan wrote in a recent analysis for Lawfare. “When it returns to the fold, it will want its money back.”
Biden to meet with leaders of Sweden and Finland
President Joe Biden will meet at the White House with the leaders of Sweden and Finland on Thursday to discuss those nations’ application for membership in NATO, the White House announced Tuesday. The meeting with Prime Minister Magdalena Andersson of Sweden and President Sauli Niinistö of Finland comes days after both countries announced they would seek entry into the alliance. Their applications must be approved by all current members, however, and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has raised objections.
Still, White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre on Tuesday reiterated Secretary of State Antony Blinken’s comments Sunday that there is strong support within NATO for Sweden and Finland to join and there are ongoing conversations with Turkey.
“We have every confidence that there will be a consensus,” Jean-Pierre said.
– Maureen Groppe
Retired colonel on Russian TV: War is going badly and will ‘frankly, get worse’
A retired Russian colonel broke from the Kremlin narrative of the war in Ukraine this week, warning on Russian TV that as the West ramps up its arms deliveries “a million armed Ukrainian soldiers needs to be viewed as a reality of the very near future.” Thus the Russian’s military struggles are likely to “frankly, get worse,” Mikhail Khodaryonok said.
Khodaryonok said Russia faced “full geopolitical isolation.” The Russian TV host, Olga Skabeyeva, known as the “Iron doll of Putin TV” for her fiercely pro-Kremlin takes, suggested that the isolation was only from the West. But Khodaryonok said support from China and India was not as unconditional as the support Ukraine was receiving from the U.S. and its allies.
“Virtually the entire world is against us,” he said, as translated by the BBC’s Francis Scarr. “And it’s that situation that we need to get out of.”
Khodaryonok also dismissed claims that the Ukraine military includes relatively few professional soldiers and was suffering from low morale.
“A desire to protect one’s homeland, in the sense that it exists in Ukraine, it really does exist there,” he said. “They intend to fight until the last man.”
Ukraine military command lauds value of steel mill holdout
Hundreds of Ukraine fighters who held on for weeks at the Azovstal steel plant in Mariupol were able to keep Russia from shifting up to 20,000 personnel to other locations in Ukraine, the Ukrainian military said in a statement. That gave the military “the opportunity to prepare and create the defensive frontiers on which our troops are still present today,” the statement said.
“We got the critically needed time to build reserves, regroup forces, and get help from partners,” the statement said.
The most important joint task of all Ukraine and the whole world is to save the lives of Mariupol defenders, the statement added: “We will fight for you on all fronts as devotedly as you defend the country.”
A big primary day on Tuesday featured the apparent defeat of controversial congressman Madison Cawthorn in North Carolina and a struggle for Dr. Mehmet Oz in Pennsylvania.
Those races highlighted a day of primaries that also included contests in Kentucky, Idaho and Oregon.
Cawthorn, plagued by ethics complaints and embarrassing videos, conceded a close race to state senator Chuck Edwards, who had the backing of prominent North Carolina Republicans who disliked the incumbent.
Dr. Oz, meanwhile, found himself locked in a tight battle against businessman David McCormick, with conservative commentator Kathy Barnette in third, for the Pennsylvania GOP Senate nomination. Oz has the backing of former President Donald Trump, but other Republicans called the television doctor too much of a liberal.
The winner faces Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, who won the Democratic nomination for the Senate seat in Pennsylvania, despite the fact that he suffered a stroke just a few days ago..
Party feuds mark races in Idaho – the Republican governor faces the Republican lieutenant governor – and Oregon, where two well-funded Democrats face off for nomination in a newly created congressional district,
Establishment Dem defeats activist in Kentucky House race
An establishment-backed state lawmaker won the Democratic primary for Kentucky’s only Democrat-held U.S. House seat Tuesday, defeating an activist who drew national attention during protests over the police killing of Breonna Taylor.
Morgan McGarvey, the top Democrat in the Kentucky Senate, defeated state Rep. Attica Scott, a former Louisville council member.
McGarvey held a big fundraising advantage and an endorsement from incumbent U.S. Rep. John Yarmuth, the House Budget Committee chair who is retiring after 15 years in the seat. McGarvey, an attorney, was also endorsed by several state lawmakers and labor unions.
Scott, a Black woman, was arrested during 2020 protests over Taylor’s death. But she was also called a “fraud” by Taylor’s mom, who suggested that those involved in the protests were raising money off her daughter’s name.
Louisville — the state’s largest city — remains a Democratic stronghold while most of Kentucky is solidly Republican.
— Associated Press
Democrat Jasmine Beach-Ferrara to face state Sen. Chuck Edwards in November
Local official Jasmine Beach-Ferrara defeated five other candidates in North Carolina’s Democratic House primary for the 11th Congressional District.
The LGBTQ activist and ordained minister will run against state Sen. Chuck Edwards, who defeated GOP incumbent Rep. Madison Cawthorn in the Republican primary.
In a phone interview with the Citizen Times, a USA TODAY Network paper, Beach-Ferrara said she’s “honored to be the Democratic nominee for Congress.”
The GOP is favored to win the district.
— Mabinty Quarshie
Idaho Gov. Brad Little defeats Trump-endorsed challenger
Idaho Gov. Brad Little defeated his Trump-endorsed challenger, Lt. Gov. Janice McGeachin, in the state’s GOP gubernatorial primary.
Little has been ahead in the polls and favored to win, but McGeachin gained far-right support throughout the race.
The race has been a test of former President Donald Trump’s power in the party up against a more traditional Republican in Little.
Both Republican Senate contenders exuded confidence in remarks to supporters, but warned them that votes will have to be counted throughout Wednesday morning,
Republican Sen. Mike Crapo has won the GOP primary for U.S. Senate in Idaho.
Crapo is seeking a fifth term and will be heavily favored in November in the conservative state.
The last time Democrats won a U.S. Senate election in Idaho was 1974.
Crapo was an attorney before he entered politics and previously served in the U.S. House and the Idaho Legislature. He is currently the ranking member of the Senate Finance Committee.
— Associated Press
A progressive and four-term senator claim victory in Oregon
Former Oregon state House Speaker Tina Kotek, a progressive, won the state’s Democratic gubernatorial primary Tuesday, defeating state Treasurer Tobias Read. The GOP race had not been called just before midnight.
Incumbent Ron Wyden easily won the state’s Democratic U.S. Senate primary.
Wyden is seeking his fifth term in the Senate and is expected to win the reliably blue state in November.
— Candy Woodall
Pennsylvania GOP Senate primary still close
As midnight neared, the Pennsylvania GOP Senate race between Dr. Mehmet Oz and David McCormick remained uncalled – and could trigger an automatic recount.
“Unfortunately, we’re not going to have resolution tonight,” McCormick told supporters shorty after 11:35 p.m.
Dr. Oz and McCormick were within 0.5% of each other, the figure that would trigger an automatic recount.
Oz had the Donald Trump endorsement, but some Pennsylvania Republicans questioned the television doctor’s commitment to conservatism and went for one of the other candidates.
Kathy Barnette, a commentator who is popular in conservative media, raced up pre-election polls in the weeks after Trump’s endorsement of Oz. She she lagged in third place behind Oz and McCormick.
McCormick, who led the race for hours, had support from former Trump officials like ex-Secretary of State Mike Pompeo. He also self-funded a campaign with a notable voter turnout operation.
Oz predicted ultimate victory, but told his backers: “We’re not going to have a result tonight.”
The Republican nominee winner takes on Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, who won the Democratic primary for the U.S. Senate in Pennsylvania.
— David Jackson
Black candidates make history in Ky. and Penn. primaries
At least two Black Democrats are making history after Tuesday’s primary elections in Kentucky and Pennsylvania.
Former state Rep. Charles Booker became the first Black person in Kentucky to win a Democratic nomination for U.S. Senate — and any statewide office.
“If anybody tells you that ceilings can’t break, tell them: ‘Look at Kentucky,’” he told supporters Tuesday night, according to the Courier Journal.
In Pennsylvania, state Rep. Austin Davis won the Democratic nomination for lieutenant governor. If he wins in the fall, Davis would become Pennsylvania’s first Black lieutenant governor.
“I stand on the shoulders of my parents — a union bus driver and a hairdresser,” Davis said in a statement Tuesday. “Because of them, I was a first-generation college graduate. Because of them, we’re going to elect Pennsylvania’s first Black lieutenant governor.”
— Candy Woodall
Cawthorn concedes to Edwards in NC primary
First-term U.S. Rep. Madison Cawthorn has conceded to North Carolina state Sen. Chuck Edwards in the Republican congressional primary, the Associated Press reported. The AP called the race shortly after.
Edwards was endorsed by Republican Sen. Thom Tillis in March after Cawthorn prompted criticism from Republican leaders for claiming that lawmakers in Washington use cocaine and hold orgies.
More recently, Cawthorn attempted to bring a loaded gun through a Charlotte airport.
“We all love freedom,” Mastriano told supporters, saying that people who believe in things like abortion rights and mask mandates are the real extremists.
Citing Bible scripture, Mastriano also told the crowd: “God is good.”
Mastriano now faces Democratic nominee Josh Shapiro, who denounced the Republican candidate as “a dangerous extremist.”
In a written statement, Shapiro said Mastriano “wants to ban abortion without exceptions, restrict the right to vote and spread conspiracy theories, and destroy the union way of life.”
Outspoken Trump backer Mastriano nominated for governor of Pennsylvania
Doug Mastriano, a Donald Trump backer and outspoken “election denier,” won the Republican nomination for governor of Pennsylvania, despite warnings from some GOP members that he is too far right to win a general election.
Mastriano, who worked aggressively to try and reverse Trump’s loss to President Joe Biden in Pennsylvania, defeated a field of Republicans who had argued that he was too extreme for most Pennsylvanians.
A state senator and a retired Army colonel, Mastriano was spotted near the U.S. Capitol during the pro-Trump insurrection of Jan. 6, 2021, though he said he never entered the building.
His opponent in the fall gubernatorial election in Pennsylvania will be Attorney General Josh Shapiro, who won the Democratic primary unopposed.
Mastriano defeated a Republican field that included former U.S. Rep. Lou Barletta, whom Trump had endorsed in a 2018 U.S. Senate race. The GOP race also featured former U.S. Attorney Bill McSwain, whom Trump endorsed against by saying he did not try hard enough to overturn the 2020 election.
In the campaign’s closing days, Barletta urged other GOP candidates to unite behind him against Mastriano, saying “it is important for Republicans to get behind one candidate who can win a nomination and then actually beat Josh Shapiro in November.”
In his endorsement of Mastriano, Trump stressed his post-election efforts. He said Mastriano “has been with me right from the beginning, and now I have an obligation to be with him.”
President Joe Biden said Tuesday night electing John Fetterman to the U.S. Senate would be “a big step forward for Pennsylvania’s working people.”
He also waded into the waters of the Senate GOP primary and repeated a phrase he’s shared in recent weeks, asserting that the current Republican Party is “not your father’s GOP.”
“They have fought a malicious, chaotic primary campaign to be the most extreme,” Biden said.
“And they have shown people their authentic selves – that whoever emerges will be too dangerous, too craven, and too extreme to represent Pennsylvania in the United States Senate.”
— Candy Woodall
John Fetterman wins Dem nomination for U.S. Senate
Fetterman has polled double-digits ahead of the competition for months and attracted more than 200,000 individual donors throughout his campaign—the most of any candidate in either party in the state’s U.S. Senate race.
Despite his lead throughout the campaign, questions mounted in recent days about whether a recent stroke would change the trajectory of the race. Voters answered those questions Tuesday when they delivered a win for Fetterman and put his name on the ballot in November.
The blockbuster leak of a draft Supreme Court opinion overturning the landmark Roe v. Wade decision jolted a midterm election season already underway.
Democrats believe public opinion is on their side, and President Joe Biden set out to frame the potential Roe decision as the latest example of an extreme “ultra MAGA agenda.”
Republican strategists said the midterms will ultimately be a referendum on the past two years of Democratic control, with voters more concerned about rising inflation and an influx of migrants at the southern border.
Pennsylvania Republicans in Allegheny County, where Pittsburgh is located, are in court to seek a voting extension, according to the Associated Press.
The county is Pennsylvania’s second-largest population base, and multiple precincts there ran out of ballots.
Lancaster County, another large county in Pennsylvania, earlier reported that at least 21,000 mailed ballots could not be read because of a printing error. They will take several days to process.
For the first time, voting materials were offered in Chinese in Philadelphia. It was the first time Asian language appeared on any Pennsylvania ballot.
Voters were previously able to vote in English and Spanish only.
— Candy Woodall
Results: Cheri Beasley wins North Carolina Democratic Senate primary
Former chief justice of the North Carolina Supreme Court Cheri Beasley easily won the Democratic primary to replace retiring GOP Sen. Richard burr’s Senate seat Tuesday.
Beasley’s top competitor state Sen. Jeff Jackson dropped out the race last year and threw his support for her. Beasley has also consistently out fundraised both Republican and Democratic candidates. She raised over $3.6 million in the first three months of this year, according to her campaign.
If Beasley is elected in the general election in November, she will be the Tarheel State’s first black senator.
— Mabinty Quarshie
Results: Rep. Ted Budd wins North Carolina GOP Senate primary
Republican Rep. Ted Budd bested 14 opponents including former Gov. Pat McCrory and state Rep. Mark Walker to win North Carolina’s open Senate primary seat Tuesday night.
Budd’s victory, called by the AP shortly after polls closed, is another notch in Donald Trump’s endorsement belt. The former president endorsed Budd nearly a year ago.
McCrory was painted as a Republican in name only by the conservative Club for Growth. He is also most-known for signing North Carolina’s bathroom bill” in 2016, which prohibited trans people from using restrooms that matched their gender identity.
Budd will likely face Democrat Cheri Beasley in the general election in November.
— Mabinty Quarshie
Kentucky election : Rand Paul wins re-nomination as U.S. senator
The first call of the night has been made, and it is not a shock: U.S. Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky has won re-nomination.
The Republican incumbent is also favored to win the general election in the fall.
Paul defeated five little-known challengers in the Republican primary Tuesday, and the Associated Press called the race just ten minutes after all the polls closed.
Paul will be opposed by Charles Booker, an unsuccessful 2020 Senate candidate who won the Democratic primary in Kentucky on Tuesday.
— David Jackson
Fetterman says surgery was successful
Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, a Democratic frontrunner in the U.S. Senate primary race, said Tuesday evening his medical procedure to implant a pacemaker with a defibrillator was successful.
“We got the all-clear that it was successful, and that I’m on track for a full recovery,” he said in a statement. “Thank yinz for the well-wishes – it means the world to me. Now back to resting + recovering!”
Fetterman shared the update on his health an hour and 40 minutes before the polls closed in Pennsylvania.
U.S. Penn. Senate race will be a “toss up” regardless who wins primary, analyst says
The U.S. Senate race in Pennsylvania will be a “toss up” regardless of who wins the Democratic and Republican primaries Tuesday, an analyst said.
And if there are any changes, the political pendulum is more likely to swing toward “leaning Republican” than “leaning Democrat,” especially if Lt. Gov. John Fetterman wins the Democratic nomination, J. Miles Coleman, associate editor of Sabato’s Crystal Ball, said Tuesday.
“Short answer is we’ll see how the cards fall after the primary, but Leans R seems a likelier potential move than Leans D, *if* we had to change it,” he said on Twitter.
Pennsylvania is always a major battleground and one of the most consequential states in midterm and presidential elections. It’s the state that delivered President Joe Biden the White House in 2020 and helped to send a record number of women to Congress in 2018. This year, the U.S. Senate race in Pennsylvania could determine which party controls the upper chamber of Congress in 2023.
In addition to Pennsylvania, Sabato’s Crystal Ball has three other states rated as “toss ups” in the 2022 U.S. Senate race: Arizona, Georgia and Nevada.
Though Sabato’s Crystal Ball has predicted Republicans to win the majority of U.S. Senate races, forecasters there said outlooks in Arizona and Pennsylvania are admittedly “murkier.”
— Candy Woodall
When do the polls close?
This primary Election Day is the first this cycle to cover several time zones, so results will roll in through the night.
Kentucky’s polls close first, at 6 p.m. local time (with the state divided in half by time zones, that means polls will close at both 6 and 7 p.m. ET). That’s followed by North Carolina at 7:30 p.m. then Pennsylvania at 8 p.m.
In the Mountain Time Zone, Idaho’s polls close at 8 p.m., or 10 p.m. ET.
And on the West Coast, Oregon’s polls close at 8 p.m. PT, or 11 p.m. ET.
– Katie Wadington
Some Pennsylvania ballots could take longer to read
At least 21,000 mail-in ballots in Pennsylvania are unreadable and will take several days to process, officials in Lancaster County said.
A printing error is the cause of the problem and seems to only be affecting ballots in Lancaster County, where voters are choosing candidates to compete for governor, lieutenant governor and U.S. Senate.
Out of the 67 counties in Pennsylvania, Lancaster County is the sixth most populous.
It will take election workers there days to redo the ballots that can’t be read by machines.
“Citizens deserve to have accurate results from elections and they deserve to have them on election night, not days later,” County Commissioner Josh Parsons said during a news conference. “But because of this, we’re not going to have final election results from these mail ballots for probably several days, so that is very, very frustrating to us.”
Pennsylvania’s Fetterman to undergo medical procedure
Pennsylvania Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, a front runner for the Democratic nomination for U.S. Senate, will undergo a medical procedure to receive a pacemaker with a defibrillator.
The pacemaker will help to protect his heart and treat the atrial fibrillation that led to his stroke, his campaign said Tuesday.
It is a “standard procedure” used to regulate heart rate and rhythm, according to the campaign.
“He’s doing great and will have a full recovery,” his wife, Gisele Fetterman, said to USA TODAY Tuesday afternoon.
John Fetterman said in a statement Sunday he went to the hospital Friday, where he was treated for a stroke. He remains hospitalized at Penn Medicine Lancaster General Hospital, but said doctors expect him to make a full recovery.
Fetterman said his stroke was caused by a blood clot from his heart being in an irregular rhythm for too long.
The doctors quickly treated him and removed the clot, effectively reversing the stroke, he said. Fetterman added that he suffered no cognitive damage.
He cast his vote Tuesday from his hospital room using an emergency absentee ballot.
Pennsylvania’s Democratic Senate primary a contrast in styles
The Democratic primary for Pennsylvania’s open U.S. Senate seat pits a pair of politicians building different kinds of support.
Pittsburgh-area Rep. Conor Lamb has built a wave of support among his party’s elected officials in Pennsylvania. The state’s Democratic Party backed him in the primary alongside throngs of elected Democrats.
But Lamb has trailed Lt. Gov. John Fetterman substantially in the public polling done on the race. A former steel town mayor, Fetterman unseated an incumbent in 2018 to become the state’s lieutenant governor.
Fetterman has largely eschewed endorsements from the state’s top Democrats while rising to the top of the polls. He has fended off attacks from Lamb and other candidates in the race that he is extreme.
Pennsylvania Lt. Gov. John Fetterman’s storied rise through politics may reach a new milestone today as he enters the Democratic Senate primary a heavy favorite. The 6 foot 9 inch Fetterman whose preference for collared work shirts over suits first drew national attention for his role as mayor of Braddock, a hollowed-out steel town he is credited with reviving. What to know about Fetterman.
Voters have picked Democratic House Rep. Conor Lamb over a Republican opponent three times. Lamb flipped a Republican House seat blue in a 2018 special election. His experience in Congress and prior election victories in Pennsylvania have made him the preferred candidate of major organizations like the Philadelphia Inquirer and the Philadelphia Democratic Party. Still, Lamb has lagged in the polls behind Fetterman and will need to defy expectations to become his party’s nominee. What to know about Lamb.
Cawthorn faces primary challenger backed by Tillis in crowded field
GOP Rep. Madison Cawthorn, who has run afoul of his party’s leadership during his first term in Congress, now faces a jumbled primary field that includes a candidate with the backing of one of North Carolina’s top Republicans.
U.S. Sen. Thom Tillis endorsed Cawthorn’s most well-funded primary opponent, state Sen. Chuck Edwards, in March. The endorsement came shortly after Cawthorn was scolded by House Minority Leader Rep. Kevin McCarthy over Cawthorn’s claim on a podcast that members of Congress were engaging in cocaine-fueled orgies.
At 26, Cawthorn is the youngest member of Congress. He has faced criticism for trying to bring a gun through airport security and for charges of driving with a revoked license.
North Carolina primaries set up general election battleground for Senate control
The candidates who emerge from North Carolina’s major party primaries for U.S. Senate will be on the frontline in the fight for control over the upper chamber.
Former President Donald Trump is backing Rep. Ted Budd, who has surged ahead of former Gov. Pat McCrory, former Rep. Mark Walker and a host of other candidates in Republican primary polls.
The winner is likely to face former North Carolina Supreme Court Justice Cheri Beasley, who is running in a large field of Democrats. Beasley has been amassing a war chest to help propel her in the primary and general elections.
Trump narrowly edged out President Joe Biden in North Carolina in the 2020 election. The Cook Political Report and Sabato’s Crystal Ball both rate the seat as “leans Republican.”
Three states — Pennsylvania, Oregon and Idaho — will on Tuesday select their party’s candidates for governor.
In Pennsylvania, just one Democrat is seeking to take the spot of incumbent Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf, who is term-limited: Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro. Leading the Republican primary is state Sen. Doug Mastriano, whose efforts to overturn the 2020 election in favor of Trump and ties to QAnon have raised concerns both in and outside the party. He currently leads the nine-person field by an average of 10 points, according to Real Clear Politics’ latest polling.
Oregon’s gubernatorial race is a crowded field. An astonishing 15 Democrats and 19 Republicans are running to replace incumbent Democratic Gov. Kate Brown, who is term-limited. A gubernatorial race hasn’t been this unsettled since 2002, when three viable candidates each from both sides of the aisle battled it out in the two primaries, the Salem Statesman-Journal reported.
And in Idaho, a bitter civil war stirs between sitting Gov. Brad Little and sitting Lt. Gov. Janice McGeachin, who will face off in the state’s Republican primary Tuesday. The governor and lieutenant governor of Idaho don’t run for office on a joint ticket, according to the Idaho Capital Sun. On the Democratic ballot is only Stephen Heidt, an English as a Second Language teacher at Idaho’s state prisons who filed his candidacy the day before the state deadline, the Idaho State Journal reported.
In Oregon’s Republicans primary, seven candidates in the hunt. The contest will pit political novices against several candidates who have run for or held public office before. The winner of the Republican primary will be qualified for the general election in November.
That winning candidate will face the winner of the Democratic primary.
Three candidates, including Wyden, are competing in the Democratic primary.
– Adam Duvernay, The Register-Guard
Trump influence on the ballot in Pennsylvania GOP Senate primary
Former President Donald Trump’s hold over the Republican Party again will be tested in Pennsylvania’s GOP primary for an open U.S. Senate seat.
Oz is trying to capture some of the same magic from Trump’s backing that propelled author J.D. Vance from his middling showing in polls to winning a crowded race for Ohio’s GOP Senate primary.
A Fox News poll released May 10 showed a tight three-way race in the GOP primary. Oz still had a small lead over McCormick in the poll, 22% to 20%, but Barnette was surging. After capturing only 9% in a March survey, Barnette was up to 19% in the latest Fox poll.
After the poll was released, Trump released a statement saying Barnette didn’t have a chance to win the general election but praised her as having “a wonderful future in the Republican Party” if she goes on to win the primary.
– Rick Rouan
Who is Mehmet Oz?
Donald Trump tapped TV host Mehmet Oz, better known as Dr. Oz, to be his candidate in the Senate race in Pennsylvania. Oz hopes Trump’s influence will come to bear in the same way it did in the Ohio Senate race, where the former president lifted conservative commentator and political outsider J.D. Vance from the middle of the pack in the polls to the GOP primary victory. But Oz is far from a comfortable favorite. He hasn’t managed to put much distance between him and his opponents in the polls in what has come down to a three-way race. What to know about Oz.
Kathy Barnette’s late surge alarmed many in the GOP, including Trump, who in a statement last week said he believed Barnette could not win a general election. Now the previously little-known conservative commentator is in a virtual three-way tie atop the polls heading into today’s primary. What to know about Barnette.
A former George W. Bush administration official, McCormick had spent the earlier part of the race jockeying with Oz for Trump’s endorsement. A bid that ultimately failed. Nonetheless, McCormick, who headed a hedge fund before his Senate run, has tried to assure voters that he is the closest aligned to Trump’s “America First” agenda. What to know about McCormick.
In one of the most competitive Oregon gubernatorial primaries in decades, 34 candidates from both sides of the aisle will find out after Tuesday night who will move on to November’s general election with a chance to secure Oregon’s governorship.
A Republican hasn’t held the state’s top elected office in 35 years, but most of the 19 candidates have said this year could represent a perfect storm for the Oregon GOP. There are growing conspicuous problems in the state (such as homelessness) and rising daily expenses due to national inflation they can try to pin on Democrats, as well as the historical advantage the out-of-power party has during a midterm election and the unknown impact of nonaffiliated candidate, former Sen. Betsy Johnson.
State political analysts believe the top candidates in the race on the Republican side are: conservative writer Bridget Barton, former Oregon House Republican Leader Christine Drazan, tech CEO Jessica Gomez, Salem oncologist Dr. Bud Pierce, Sandy Mayor Stan Pulliam and former Oregon Rep. Bob Tiernan.
On the Democratic side, former Oregon House Speaker Tina Kotek and Oregon Treasurer Tobias Read lead a field of 15 candidates. They both have been deeply engaged in Oregon politics for years, but say the problems the state faces now can be attributed to failures outside of their control.
They contend their particular backgrounds and understanding of how state government functions have prepared them to lead Oregon.
KYIV/MARIUPOL, Ukraine, May 18 (Reuters) – Concerns grew on Wednesday for the welfare of more than 250 Ukrainian fighters who surrendered to Russian forces at the Azovstal steelworks in Mariupol after weeks of desperate resistance.
The surrender brought an end to the most devastating siege of Russia’s war in Ukraine and allowed President Vladimir Putin to claim a rare victory in his faltering campaign, which many military analysts say has stalled. read more
Buses left the steelworks late on Monday in a convoy escorted by Russian armoured vehicles. Five arrived in the Russian-held town of Novoazovsk, where Moscow said wounded fighters would be treated.
Seven buses carrying Ukrainian fighters from the Azovstal garrison arrived at a newly reopened prison in the Russian-controlled town of Olenivka near Donetsk, a Reuters witness said.
Russia said at least 256 Ukrainian fighters had “laid down their arms and surrendered”, including 51 severely wounded. Ukraine said 264 soldiers, including 53 wounded, had left.
Russian defence ministry video showed fighters leaving the plant, some carried on stretchers, others with hands up to be searched by Russian troops.
There were some women aboard at least one of the buses in Olenivka, Reuters video showed.
While both sides spoke of a deal under which all Ukrainian troops would abandon the steelworks, many details were not yet public, including how many fighters still remained inside, and whether any form of prisoner swap had been agreed.
The Kremlin said Putin had personally guaranteed the prisoners would be treated according to international standards, and Ukrainian officials said they could be exchanged for Russian captives.
Ukrainian Deputy Prime Minister Iryna Vereshchuk said Kyiv aimed to arrange a prisoner swap for the wounded once their condition stabilised.
Russian Deputy Ambassador to the United Nations Dmitry Polyansky said there had been no deal, tweeting: “I didn’t know English has so many ways to express a single message: the #Azovnazis have unconditionally surrendered.”
TASS news agency reported a Russian committee planned to question the soldiers, many of them members of the Azov Battalion, as part of an investigation into what Moscow calls “Ukrainian regime crimes”.
High-profile Russian lawmakers spoke out against any prisoner swap. Vyacheslav Volodin, speaker of the State Duma, Russia’s lower house, said: “Nazi criminals should not be exchanged.”
Lawmaker Leonid Slutsky, one of Russia’s negotiators in talks with Ukraine, called the evacuated combatants “animals in human form” and said they should be executed.
Formed in 2014 as an extreme right-wing volunteer militia to fight Russian-backed separatists, the Azov Regiment denies being fascist or neo-Nazi. Ukraine says it has been reformed and integrated into the National Guard.
Natalia, the wife of a sailor among those holed up in the plant, told Reuters she hoped “there will be an honest exchange”. But she was still worried: “What Russia is doing now is inhumane.”
On the diplomatic front, U.S. President Joe Biden will host the leaders of Sweden and Finland at the White House on Thursday to discuss their NATO applications, the White House said. The Nordic countries are optimistic they can overcome objections from Turkey over jointing the 30-nation alliance. read more
BATTLE FOR DONBAS
The denouement of the battle for Mariupol is Russia’s biggest victory since it launched what it calls a “special military operation” in Ukraine on Feb. 24.
It gives Moscow control of the Azov Sea coast and an unbroken stretch of eastern and southern Ukraine. But the port lies in ruins, and Ukraine believes tens of thousands of people were killed under months of Russian bombardment.
Russia’s offensive in the east, meanwhile, appeared to be making little progress, although the Kremlin says all its objectives will be reached.
Ukraine’s military command said Russia continued to shell Ukrainian positions along the entire frontline in the east on Wednesday.
“In the Kharkiv direction, the enemy focused on maintaining its positions and preventing the further advance of our troops,” Ukraine’s general staff said in a statement.
Around a third of the Donbas was held by Russia-backed separatists before the invasion. Moscow now controls around 90% of Luhansk region, but it has failed to make major inroads towards the key cities of Sloviansk and Kramatorsk in Donetsk in order to extend control over the entire Donbas.
Ukrainian forces have advanced at their fastest pace for more than a month, driving Russian forces out of the area around Kharkiv, Ukraine’s second-largest city.
Ukraine says its forces had reached the Russian border, 40 km (25 miles) north of Kharkiv. They have also pushed at least as far as the Siverskiy Donets river 40 km to the east, where they could threaten Russian supply lines.
Putin may have to decide whether to send more troops and hardware to replenish his weakened invasion force as an influx of Western weapons, including scores of U.S. and Canadian M777 howitzers that have longer range than their Russian equivalents, bolsters Ukraine’s combat power, analysts said.
“Time is definitely working against the Russians … The Ukrainians are getting stronger almost every day,” said Neil Melvin of the RUSI think-tank in London.
Rep. Ted Budd is the Republican nominee for North Carolina’s open Senate seat, while Cheri Beasley is the Democratic nominee.
Chris Seward/AP; Gerry Broome/AP
hide caption
toggle caption
Chris Seward/AP; Gerry Broome/AP
Rep. Ted Budd is the Republican nominee for North Carolina’s open Senate seat, while Cheri Beasley is the Democratic nominee.
Chris Seward/AP; Gerry Broome/AP
Rep. Ted Budd, who was supported in the Republican primary by former President Donald Trump, will face off against Democrat Cheri Beasley in the closely watched North Carolina U.S. Senate election, according to race calls by The Associated Press.
In the GOP primary, Budd fended off opponents including former Gov. Pat McCrory.
Beasley, who was the first Black woman to serve as chief justice of the North Carolina Supreme Court, faced light opposition for the Democratic nomination. She coasted to the top after her main primary competitor dropped out of the race in December.
Budd had a consistent lead in polls over McCrory for months. The former president weighed in early, backing Budd last June over McCrory and former Rep. Mark Walker.
The race exposed fractures in the Republican Party between more establishment candidates and ones Trump has endorsed.
Trump’s somewhat-surprising choice for Budd boosted the relatively unknown congressman’s standing. Budd was also helped by outside money, namely millions of dollars in support from Club for Growth‘s PAC.
McCrory, who gained national prominence when he signed the state’s “bathroom bill,” failed to shape a strong message against Budd, despite nearly matching him in fundraising efforts.
The Senate race is another competitive contest that has high stakes for both parties. The seat is open thanks to the retirement of GOP Sen. Richard Burr, and Cook Political Report predicts the seat will lean toward staying red.
But Beasley raised $1 million in April and has more cash on hand than her Republican counterpart, in part because the Democratic primary was far less competitive.
Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Cheri Beasley, center, laughs with husband Curtis Owens, right, at a campaign event in February while son Matthew Owens watches. Beasley won the Democratic Senate primary Tuesday, according to the AP.
Gary D. Robertson/AP
hide caption
toggle caption
Gary D. Robertson/AP
Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Cheri Beasley, center, laughs with husband Curtis Owens, right, at a campaign event in February while son Matthew Owens watches. Beasley won the Democratic Senate primary Tuesday, according to the AP.
Gary D. Robertson/AP
Republican Rep. Ted Budd shakes hands with former President Donald Trump during a rally in April.
Chris Seward/AP
hide caption
toggle caption
Chris Seward/AP
Republican Rep. Ted Budd shakes hands with former President Donald Trump during a rally in April.
(CNN)President Joe Biden on Tuesday did not hesitate to call the deadly mass shooting in Buffalo, New York, an act of domestic terrorism, condemning the racist ideology of the suspected shooter.
“Today, yes, it is a great celebration for so many reasons, so many things,” Harris said. “But it is also impossible to ignore that we gather mere days after a horrific act of hate in Buffalo, New York, targeting Black Americans. And you know, it was only last year, as (Ambassador Katherine Tai) said, only last year that I was with the President in Atlanta, mourning the murder of eight people including six who are Asian American women. And sadly, what I said then remains true now. Racism is real in America, xenophobia is real in America. It always has been. Sexism is too.”
CNN’s Betsy Klein, Donald Judd, Arlette Saenz, Nikki Carvajal, Victor Blackwell, Amanda Watts, Eric Levenson and Travis Caldwell contributed to this report.
The Orange County district attorney filed a murder charge Tuesday that could carry the death penalty against a man accused of fatally shooting one man and wounding five other people at a Taiwanese church in what authorities have characterized as an apparent political hate crime.
One of the victims — John Cheng, a 52-year-old doctor — died from his wounds. Five others, ranging in age from 66 to 92, were taken to hospitals.
A gunman attacked a lunch banquet at a Taiwanese church in Laguna Woods, killing one person and wounding five others Sunday before congregants tackled him, hogtied him with an extension cord and grabbed his two weapons, authorities said.
In addition to the murder charge, Chou faces five counts of attempted murder, as well as murder with the special circumstance of the use of a gun and lying in wait, Dist. Atty. Todd Spitzer said. The special circumstances enhancement means that if convicted, Chou would face life in prison without parole, or the death penalty.
Chou was also charged with four counts of possession of destructive devices with intention to kill or harm.
Chou appeared in Orange County Superior court by audio only on Tuesday. He could not appear on video based on his location in the jail, officials said.
His arraignment was postponed until June 10. A Mandarin interpreter was used to translate the proceedings.
Judge Cynthia Herrera ordered that Chou be held without bail.
When a man began shooting at the congregants — most of them elderly and Taiwanese — Dr. John Cheng put himself in the line of fire.
Orange County Sheriff Don Barnes on Monday characterized the shooting as a “politically motivated hate incident,” and said authorities think Chou “specifically targeted the Taiwanese community.”
The FBI has also opened a federal hate crime investigation into the shooting.
Prosecutors have not yet filed a hate crime sentencing enhancement in the case, but Spitzer said his team is working with the FBI to explore that evidence.
“While there’s very strong evidence right now that this was motivated by hate, we want to make sure that we have put together all the evidence that confirms that theory,” Spitzer told reporters during a briefing Tuesday.
Spitzer said he wants to “continue to work with our law enforcement partners and the FBI to get all the additional evidence, so that if we file a hate crime enhancement, we’ve done it knowing full well what the evidence is.”
Spitzer met with the FBI on Monday and said the agency has interpreters and other specialists reviewing evidence. He said there also are statutes under federal law that those authorities could consider filing in this case.
“They have statutes that we don’t have. For example, they have a statute under federal law of engaging in terrorist acts or injury to others or murder in a house of worship,” he said.
Barnes said Chou left notes in Chinese in his car stating he did not believe Taiwan should be independent from China, and apparently had an issue with Taiwanese people because of the way he was treated while living there.
Originally, Barnes said Chou was born in mainland China and relocated to Taiwan at some point before moving to the United States. However, the Sheriff’s Department said Tuesday evening that additional information had come to light that this wasn’t the case.
“The information regarding his nationality was provided to us during interviews with people familiar with the suspect, while communicating through interpreters,” department spokeswoman Carrie Braun said in a statement. “While later speaking with the suspect, he indicated that he was born and raised in Taiwan.”
An official from the Taipei Economic and Cultural Office in Los Angeles — Taiwan’s de facto embassy, since the island is not officially recognized by the U.S. and most other countries — also said Chou was born in Taiwan.
China considers Taiwan a breakaway province and has grown increasingly aggressive about reclaiming the democratic, self-ruled island. Within Taiwan, a majority of people favor maintaining the status quo, with some wanting to openly declare independence and a small minority wanting to someday unify with China.
“According to the suspect’s writings that have been interpreted, he fostered a grievance against the Taiwanese community and he was upset about the political tensions between China and Taiwan,” Braun said.
Irvine Taiwanese Presbyterian Church, whose members were the target of an attack authorities allege was a politically motivated hate incident, released a letter that offered new insights into the events of the hours before the shooting and its direct aftermath.
In the months leading up to the shooting, Chou dealt with upheaval in his personal life. His wife had returned to Taiwan in December, to seek treatment for cancer but also to leave him in the midst of a divorce — according to Balmore Orellana, their former neighbor in Las Vegas.
Chou and his wife owned the building they lived in, but sold it around the time she left for Taiwan, Orellana said, and Chou later complained to him that the new owners raised the rent to an unaffordable level.
Orellana said Chou was evicted in February.
According to Orellana, Chou said he was born in Taiwan but considered himself Chinese and believed China and Taiwan were one country.
Irvine Taiwanese Presbyterian Church, whose members were the target of an attack authorities allege was a politically motivated hate incident, released a letter that offered new insights into the events of the hours before the shooting and its direct aftermath.
In a letter released Monday, the Irvine Taiwanese Presbyterian Church alleged Chou arrived at the church around 10 a.m. Sunday, before the morning service. He was wearing a black shirt that some parishioners believed said “Security,” the church said. Chou worked intermittently as a security guard in Las Vegas, according to Orellana.
He apparently stayed in the church area until the early afternoon, when he emerged at a banquet hall where the church was honoring longtime Pastor Billy Chang, who had just returned after two years in Taiwan.
Spitzer said Chou set up a scenario in which he made people inside the church feel comfortable.
“This case is about the person concealing themselves in plain view,” he said, adding that the suspect led everyone to believe he was there “to celebrate the life of Jesus and the pastor coming back from Taiwan.”
It is not clear why Chou chose to carry out the attack specifically on Sunday. Spitzer said there has been evidence collected that “could indicate that this church was just random and it could have been any other Taiwanese church.” He stressed that officials are still working through that evidence.
After the lunch, some churchgoers ran into Chou, whom they saw “applying iron chains to start locking the doors shut,” the church said in the letter.
Other church members saw him hammering shut two other doors with nails, the letter said. Authorities also allege the suspect tried to disable locks with superglue.
The church said Chou then fired a shot into the air; some in the room assumed the sound was balloons popping.
“Dr. John Cheng saw Chou with the gun and immediately took action to try to stop him. Chou shot Dr. Cheng dead with three bullets. Some church members then fell to the floor,” the church said.
‘It is believed the suspect involved was upset about political tensions between China and Taiwan,’ Orange County Sheriff Don Barnes said.
Cheng’s actions have widely been praised as heroic — with officials saying his intervention gave other parishioners the opportunity to subdue the suspect.
“Without the actions of Dr. Cheng, it is no doubt that there would be numerous additional victims in this crime,” Barnes said.
After Cheng attempted to stop the gunman, Chang, the former pastor, ran up to him with a chair as his weapon.
“He got scared. I don’t think he expected someone to attack him,” Chang said in an interview with The Times.
Chang said he pushed the gunman to the floor, after which he and other parishioners hogtied him with an electric cord, according to officials and eyewitness accounts.
Bags containing additional ammunition, as well as four Molotov cocktail-like incendiary devices, were found at the scene, authorities said.
President Tsai Ing-wen’s office extends condolences to the victims as a Taiwanese lawmaker questions whether Chinese propaganda fueled the violence.
The Laguna Woods Christian Women’s Connection was planning a prayer walk Tuesday evening.
“I can’t believe how big this has gotten,” member Leslie Wilson said of news of the shooting — and of public concern. “Out in the community, people are talking about what else they can do to show that they care.”
Wilson, a nurse who runs a side business trimming cat nails, said her fellow Laguna Woods residents appreciate the cultural diversity in the city set up to serve retirees and she, especially, does not want the tragedy to deter seniors from moving to the area.
“It’s a beautiful thing to have those of different faith and different ethnicities choose this place to be a new home next to their native homes. We’re all connected, and when someone hurts some of us, we rise up to help,” Wilson said.
As she spoke, some senior citizens whizzed by on their golf carts, bag and clubs in tow, on their way to another 18-hole round. A few stopped at the church parking lot, asking where they could drop off money and food donations.
No one inside the congregation could come outside to answer their queries. Two women with packages stuffed with blankets said they would mail them, along with checks, to the church.
“We all are praying,” Wilson said. “Praying for answers as well as for everyone’s safety.”
Times staff writers Matthew Ormseth, Cindy Carcamo, Gregory Yee, Jeong Park, Hailey Branson-Potts and Christopher Goffard contributed to this report.
KYIV, Ukraine (AP) — Mariupol appeared on the verge of falling to the Russians on Tuesday as Ukraine moved to abandon the steel plant where hundreds of its fighters had held out for months under relentless bombardment in the last bastion of resistance in the devastated city.
More than 260 Ukrainian fighters — some of them seriously wounded and taken out on stretchers — left the ruins of the Azovstal plant on Monday and turned themselves over to the Russian side in a deal negotiated by the warring parties. An additional seven buses carrying an unknown number of Ukrainian soldiers from the plant were seen arriving at a former penal colony Tuesday in the town of Olenivka, approximately 88 kilometers (55 miles) north of Mariupol.
While Russia called it a surrender, the Ukrainians avoided that word and instead said the plant’s garrison had successfully completed its mission to tie down Russian forces and was under new orders.
“To save their lives. Ukraine needs them. This is the main thing,” Ukrainian Defense Minister Oleksiy Reznikov said.
The Ukrainians expressed hope that the fighters would be exchanged for Russian prisoners of war. But Vyacheslav Volodin, speaker of the lower house of the Russian parliament, said without evidence that there were “war criminals” among the defenders and that they should not be exchanged but tried.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said the country’s military and intelligence officers are still working to extract its remaining troops from the sprawling steel mill. Officials have not said how many remain inside.
“The most influential international mediators are involved,” he said.
The operation to abandon the steel plant and its labyrinth of tunnels and bunkers signaled the beginning of the end of a nearly three-month siege that turned Mariupol into a worldwide symbol of both defiance and suffering.
The Russian bombardment killed over 20,000 civilians, according to Ukraine, and left the remaining inhabitants — perhaps one-quarter of the southern port city’s prewar population of 430,000 — with little food, water, heat or medicine.
Gaining full control of Mariupol would give Russia an unbroken land bridge to the Crimean Peninsula, which it seized from Ukraine in 2014, and deprive Ukraine of a vital port. It could also free up Russian forces to fight elsewhere in the Donbas, the eastern industrial heartland that the Kremlin is bent on capturing.
And it would give Russia a victory after repeated setbacks on the battlefield and the diplomatic front, beginning with the abortive attempt to storm Kyiv, the capital.
The Russian victory, though, is mostly a symbolic boost for Russian President Vladimir Putin than a military win, said retired French Vice Adm. Michel Olhagaray, a former head of France’s center for higher military studies. He said: “factually, Mariupol had already fallen.”
“Now Putin can claim a ‘victory’ in the Donbas,” Olhagaray said.
But because the Azovstal defenders’ “incredible resistance” tied down Russian troops, Ukraine can also claim that it came out on top.
“Both sides will be able take pride or boast about a victory — victories of different kinds,” he said.
Ukrainian presidential adviser Mykhailo Podolyak likened the Ukrainian defenders to the vastly outnumbered Spartans who held out against Persian forces in ancient Greece. “83 days of Mariupol defense will go down in history as the Thermopylae of the XXI century,” he tweeted.
The soldiers who left the plant were searched by Russian troops, loaded onto buses accompanied by Russian military vehicles, and taken to two towns controlled by Moscow-backed separatists. More than 50 of the fighters were seriously wounded, according to both sides.
It was impossible to confirm the total number of fighters brought to Olenivka or their legal status. While both Mariupol and Olenivka are officially part of Ukraine’s eastern Donetsk region, Olenivka has been controlled by Russia-backed separatists since 2014 and forms part of the unrecognized “Donetsk People’s Republic.” Prior to the rebel takeover, penal colony No. 120 had been a high-security facility designed to hold those sentenced for serious crimes.
Footage shot by The Associated Press shows the convoy was escorted by military vehicles bearing the pro-Kremlin “Z” sign, as Soviet flags fluttered from poles along the road. About two dozen Ukrainian fighters were seen in one of the buses.
Ukraine’s human rights ombudsman said the Russian military was holding more than 3,000 civilians from Mariupol at another former penal colony near Olenivka. Ombudsman Lyudmyla Denisova said most civilians are held for a month, but those considered “particularly unreliable,” including former soldiers and police, are held for two months. The detainees include about 30 volunteers who delivered humanitarian supplies to Mariupol while it was under siege, she said.
Russia’s main federal investigative body said it intends to interrogate the troops to “identify the nationalists” and determine whether they were involved in crimes against civilians. Also, Russia’s top prosecutor asked the country’s Supreme Court to designate Ukraine’s Azov Regiment, whose members have been holding out at Azovstal, a terrorist organization. The regiment has links to the far right.
Russian state news agencies said the Russian parliament would take up a resolution Wednesday to prevent the exchange of Azov Regiment fighters.
A negotiated withdrawal could save lives on the Russian side, too, sparing its troops from what almost certainly would be a bloody battle to finish off the defenders inside the plant, which sprawls over 11 square kilometers (4 square miles).
The withdrawal could also work to Moscow’s advantage by taking the world’s attention off the suffering in Mariupol.
Russian and Ukrainian officials said peace talks were on hold.
Elsewhere across the Donbas, eight civilians were killed Tuesday in Russian attacks on 45 settlements in the Donetsk and Luhansk regions, the General Staff of the Ukrainian Armed Forces said. Donetsk regional Gov. Pavlo Kyrylenko said a Russian airstrike ignited a fire at a building materials plant. In the Luhansk region, Russian soldiers fired rockets on an evacuation bus carrying 36 civilians, but no one was hurt, Gov. Serhii Haidai said.
Zelenskyy said Russian forces also fired missiles at the western Lviv region and the Sumy and Chernihiv regions in the northeast, and carried out airstrikes in the eastern Luhansk region. He said the border regions of Ukraine saw Russian “sabotage activity.”
He said the assaults were “a test of our strength” and “kind of an attempt to compensate the Russian army for a series of failures in the east and south of our country.”
Ukrainian guerrilla fighters also killed several high-ranking Russian officers in the southern city of Melitopol, the regional administration said on Telegram. Russian forces have occupied the city since early in the war.
The report could not immediately be confirmed. Throughout the war, Ukraine has claimed to have killed many Russian generals and other officers. A few of the deaths have been confirmed by Russia.
Russian officials in Belgorod and Kursk — two regions bordering Ukraine — accused Kyiv of shelling villages and civilian infrastructure along the frontier, the latest in a series of similar accusations over the recent weeks.
In other developments, the chief prosecutor for the International Criminal Court prosecutor, Karim Khan, said he sent a team of 42 investigators, forensic experts and support personnel to Ukraine to look into suspected war crimes. Ukraine has accused Russian forces of torturing and killing civilians.
___
McQuillan and Yuras Karmanau reported from Lviv, Ukraine. Mstyslav Chernov and Andrea Rosa in Kharkiv, Elena Becatoros in Odesa and other AP staffers around the world contributed.
WASHINGTON, May 17 (Reuters) – Investigators probing the crash of a China Eastern Airlines (600115.SS) jet are examining whether it was due to intentional action taken on the flight deck, with no evidence so far of a technical malfunction, two people briefed on the matter said.
The Wall Street Journal reported earlier Tuesday that flight data from one the Boeing 737-800’s black boxes indicated that someone in the cockpit intentionally crashed the plane, citing people familiar with U.S. officials’ preliminary assessment.
Boeing Co (BA.N), the maker of the jet, and the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) declined to comment and referred questions to Chinese regulators.
The Boeing 737-800, en route from Kunming to Guangzhou, crashed on March 21 in the mountains of Guangxi, after a sudden plunge from cruising altitude, killing all 123 passengers and nine crew members aboard.
It was mainland China’s deadliest aviation disaster in 28 years. read more
The pilots did not respond to repeated calls from air traffic controllers and nearby planes during the rapid descent, authorities have said. One source told Reuters investigators were looking at whether the crash was a “voluntary” act.
Screenshots of the Wall Street Journal story appeared to be censored both on China’s Twitter-like platform Weibo and messaging app Wechat on Wednesday morning. The hashtag topics “China Eastern” and “China Eastern black boxes” are banned on Weibo, which cited a breach of relevant laws, and users are unable to share the story in group chats on Wechat.
The Civil Aviation Administration of China said on April 11 in response to rumours on the internet of a deliberate crash that the speculation had “gravely misled the public” and “interfered with the accident investigation work.”
China Eastern did not immediately respond to a request for comment Tuesday. The Wall Street Journal said the airline had said in a statement that no evidence had emerged that could determine whether or not there were any problems with the accident aircraft. The Chinese Embassy declined to comment.
The 737-800 is a widely flown predecessor to Boeing’s 737 MAX but does not have the systems that have been linked to fatal 737-MAX crashes in 2018 and 2019 that led to a lengthy grounding of the MAX.
China Eastern grounded its entire fleet of 737-800 planes after the crash, but resumed flights in mid-April in a move widely seen at the time as ruling out any immediate new safety concern over Boeing’s previous and still most widely used model.
In a summary of an unpublished preliminary crash report last month, Chinese regulators did not point to any technical recommendations on the 737-800, which has been in service since 1997 with a strong safety record, according to experts.
NTSB Chair Jennifer Homendy said in a May 10 Reuters interview that board investigators and Boeing had traveled to China to assist the Chinese investigation. She noted that the investigation to date had not found any safety issues that would require any urgent actions.
Homendy said if the board has any safety concerns it will “issue urgent safety recommendations.”
The NTSB assisted Chinese investigators with the review of black boxes at its U.S. lab in Washington.
Shares of Boeing closed up 6.5%.
A final report into the causes could take two years or more to compile, Chinese officials have said. Analysts say most crashes are caused by a cocktail of human and technical factors.
Deliberate crashes are exceptionally rare. Experts noted the latest hypothesis left open whether the action stemmed from one pilot acting alone or the result of a struggle or intrusion but sources stressed nothing has been confirmed.
In March 2015, a Germanwings co-pilot deliberately flew an Airbus A320 into a French mountainside, killing all 150 on board.
French investigators found the 27-year-old was suffering from a suspected “psychotic depressive episode,” concealed from his employer. They later called for better mental health guidelines and stronger peer support groups for pilots.
Congress held its first public hearing on unidentified flying objects in decades on Tuesday, centering on investigations about reported military encounters with unexplained objects.
By the numbers: A database tracking unidentified object sightings has grown to roughly 400 reports. Sightings “are frequent and are continuing,” witnesses said.
The report concluded that UAP could pose a threat to national security but found no evidence of aliens from the incidents.
The last hearing on UFOs was in 1966, when then-Republican House Minority Leader Gerald Ford held two hearings regarding reported sightings in Michigan and other parts of the country earlier that year.
One now-resolved unidentified aerial phenomena (UAP) video captured by the Navy was explained as lens aberrations and the aperture shape of the night vision goggles used to record the footage.
Deputy Director of Naval Intelligence Scott Bray played another video of a military flyby with a UAP that has yet to be explained.
Resolved reports fall into five explanatory categories
Airborne clutter
Natural atmospheric phenomena
U.S. government or U.S. industry developmental programs
Foreign adversary systems
“Other,” which serves as “a holding bin of difficult cases and for the possibility of surprise and potential scientific discovery,” Bray said.
There have been 11 near misses between unknown objects and U.S. military assets
U.S. service members have recorded no collisions or direct communications with UAP, Bray said.
They also have not found wreckage material “that isn’t consistent with being of terrestrial origin,” he added.
The House Intelligence Committee’s subcommittee on Counterterrorism, Counterintelligence, and Counterproliferation interviewed Defense Department officials about DOD’s work looking into the UAPs.
The Airborne Object Identification and Management Synchronization Group (AOIMSG) was established in November 2021 as the successor to the DOD’s Unidentified Aerial Phenomena Task Force, which was created in response to reports from Navy pilots and other servicemembers about encounters with UAP over several years.
Some videos from the reports were released by the Pentagon in 2020, including recorded footage from infrared cameras of fighter jets.
What they’re saying: Bray and Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence & Security Ronald Moultrie stressed that the Pentagon’s primary goals with AOIMSG are to organize and synthesize raw, abnormal data collected by service members and to identify UAP.
“We know that our service members have encountered unidentified aerial phenomena, and because UAP pose potential flight safety and general security risk, we are committed to a focused effort to determine their origin,” Moultrie said.
“Since the early 2000s, we’ve seen an increasing number of unauthorized or unidentified aircraft or objects in military-controlled training areas and training ranges and other designated airspace,” Bray said in his opening statement. “Reports of sightings are frequent and are continuing.”
The Pentagon attributes the frequency of sightings to the increased presence of commercial drones near military sites and better sensor equipment detecting debris, such as mylar balloons, in military airspace, Bray said.
The frequency could also be attributed to AOIMSG standardizing reporting procedures for Navy and Air Force service members and the Pentagon recently encouraging service members to report anything abnormal while at sea or in flight, Bray said.
This is a widget area - If you go to "Appearance" in your WP-Admin you can change the content of this box in "Widgets", or you can remove this box completely under "Theme Options"