Washington — The family of Michigan’s Paul Whelan was “astonished” Wednesday after President Joe Biden called the wife of WNBA star Brittney Griner but did not also call the Whelans.
Both Whelan and Griner are imprisoned in Russia, but Griner was arrested in February, while Whelan has been held for 3.5 years. His family has sought a meeting with Biden for months and months, with his sister, Elizabeth Whelan, putting in four requests that have not been granted, she said.
The Whelans suggested the disparate treatment is due to Griner’s celebrity. The two-time Olympic gold medalist plays for the Phoenix Mercury and faces possibly 10 years in prison in Russia.
“We are astonished at this development and feel badly for our elderly parents, and in particular for Paul,” Elizabeth Whelan told The Detroit News on Wednesday. “Does this mean he is going to be left behind yet again?”
She was referring to a prisoner swap negotiated earlier this year that led to Russia releasing Texan Trevor Reed. Reed, like Whelan, is a former U.S. Marine arrested after traveling to Russia as a tourist, but Reed was included in the prisoner swap, and Whelan was not.
The White House said Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris spoke Wednesday to Griner’s wife, Cherelle Griner, to “reassure” her that his administration is is working to secure her release, as well as the release of Whelan and other U.S. nationals who are wrongfully detained. Griner’s trial on drug charges began Friday in Moscow.
Press Secretary Karine Jean Pierre said Wednesday that Griner has been “top of mind” for Biden and that he receives daily updates about the status of negotiations to her release.
“I am crushed. If he wants to talk about securing Paul’s release, he needs to be talking to the Whelans!” Elizabeth Whelan tweeted Wednesday. “What are we to think?!”
Biden also read Cherelle Griner a draft of a letter that he is sending to Brittney in Russia, according to a readout of the call. Griner had written to Biden in a letter delivered Monday, urging him not to “forget about me and the other American detainees.”
“I’m terrified I might be here forever,” she wrote to Biden.
Notably, Biden’s call to Griner’s wife, Cherelle, came after a national CBS interview she did Tuesday, arguing that the president needed to do more to help and noting that she had not yet heard from Biden.
Whelan’s twin brother, David, said the episode says a lot about how a detainee’s family resources matter.
“I don’t begrudge Ms. Griner and her supporters their success in getting the president’s attention while he ignores so many other families,” David said.
“It suggests the only way to get the White House’s attention, under President Trump or President Biden, is to have celebrity and wealth and resources that most wrongful detainees do not have.”
David said his family will have to “wait and see” what happens, noting that Secretary of State Antony Blinken has told the family that Paul’s case remains a priority.
“At some level, we take that at face value,” David said. “Unfortunately, if it unfolds that Ms. Griner is released and Paul isn’t, again, we’ll be faced with the same question we were with the release of Trevor Reed: Is the White House only working on the cases when the president takes the time to call? And how do families explain that to their loved ones?”
Whelan is serving a 16-year sentence of hard labor at a prison camp in Mordovia. U.S. officials and lawmakers have long labeled his detention “wrongful” and pressed for his release.
In the wake of Reed’s return, State Department representatives advised the Whelan family to “make more noise” or “be a squeakier wheel,” David said.
He pointed out that they’d done 40 media interviews after Reed’s release and that Elizabeth took part in a rally outside the White House. She also has made nearly 20 visits to Capitol Hill to talk to lawmakers.
“We cannot stop talking about Americans detained abroad. My constituent Paul Whelan has been wrongfully detained since the start of 2019 — his family is desperate for his return,” U.S. Rep. Haley Stevens, D-Waterford, said Wednesday.
“I urge the Biden administration to continue to work to secure the releases of Paul and Brittney.”
Elizabeth’s last high-level meeting with the Biden administration was a May 4 sit-down with National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan. The family has received no new information in the two months since then, she said.
She would even skip the meeting with Biden if instead his effort would be put into getting her brother home, she said.
“I do want his staff to understand that there are many other detainee families who would also like this personal involvement in their cases,” Elizabeth Whelan said,” and that we can’t be expected not to feel concerned when the attention to families is so uneven.”
mburke@detroitnews.com
Source Article from https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/politics/2022/07/06/whelan-family-astonished-after-biden-calls-griners-wife/7823793001/
The first person Yana Muravinets tried to persuade to leave her home near Ukraine’s front lines was a young woman who was five months pregnant.
She did not want to abandon her cows, her calf or her dog. She told Ms. Muravinets that she put energy and money into building her house near the southern Ukrainian city of Mykolaiv, and she was afraid of losing it.
“I said: ‘None of this will be necessary when you’re lying here dead,’” Ms. Muravinets said.
Since the early days of the war Ms. Muravinets, a 27-year-old photographer and videographer from the region, has taken up a new volunteer job with the Red Cross: encouraging people to evacuate. In phone calls, doorstep conversations, public speeches in village squares, sometimes even under fire, she has tried to convince Ukrainians that leaving everything behind is the only sure way to survive.
Persuading people to abandon all they have built in a lifetime is one of the many dreary jobs the war has created, and another challenge authorities have faced. While the city of Mykolaiv managed to push back Russian attacks early in the war, strikes have pummeled it and its region, bringing widespread death and destruction. Many residents have left, but hundreds of thousands are still there, and the mayor’s office has urged people to leave.
Ms. Muravinets, who has spent thousands of hours in recent months trying to make the case for evacuating, said she was unprepared for the task. She started having panic attacks, she said, but she felt she must keep going.
“The war isn’t ending and people just keep putting themselves in danger,” she said in a Zoom call from Mykolaiv that had to be cut short because of shelling. “If I can convince one person to leave, that’s already good.”
Boris Shchabelkyi, a coordinator of evacuations of people with disabilities who works alongside Ms. Muravinets, described her as a tireless worker, gentle with the people she needs to evacuate and “always in a good mood” with her colleagues.
With the Red Cross, she has helped evacuate more than 2,500 people, she said, but many have stayed, or returned a few days after they left. It took a month and a half to convince the young pregnant woman to flee, and she left only after her home’s windows were knocked out twice, Ms. Muravinets said.
“Especially when it’s safe, people think it’s fine and live under some illusion,” she said. “They decide to leave only when missiles come to their house.”
For two years before the war, Ms. Muravinets worked for Lactalis, a French dairy company with a plant in the area, and she toured farming villages to check milk quality.
Now that many country roads have become dangerous, she has reached remote villages, avoiding fire by using shortcuts she learned in her previous job. But now, she has to persuade dairy farmers to abandon their livelihoods.
“It’s the whole life for them,” she said. “They say: ‘How can I leave my cows? How can I leave my cows?’”
Before the war, she said a cow could cost up to $1,000. Now, people take them to slaughterhouses to get meat for a fraction of that.
Ms. Muravinets said some farmers who agreed to evacuate left the corrals open, so the animals would not starve, and cows, bulls and ducks now roamed village streets looking for food and water.
“The people who had money, opportunities, cars have already left,” Ms. Muravinets said. But others, living in bunkers for months, told her that they were ready to die there because they refused to leave.
She said she was staying for the same reason.
“The people who are left are those who are ready to sacrifice their lives.”
Valeriya Safronova contributed reporting from New York.
Source Article from https://www.nytimes.com/live/2022/07/17/world/russia-ukraine-war-news